Insurance by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Insurance and Risk Science

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Variable Fee Approach for Direct Participation Contracts

Abstract. The variable fee approach (VFA) under IFRS 17 measures insurance contracts with direct participation features on the premise that an entity supplies insurance and investment-related services in return for a variable fee determined by reference to specified underlying items. Its distinctive accounting feature is the adjustment of the contractual service margin (CSM) for changes in the entity's share of underlying items and certain effects of financial risk on future service. This monograph examines the eligibility boundary established by IFRS 17, the financial interpretation of underlying items, subsequent CSM measurement, investment-related services and coverage units, guarantees and risk mitigation, disclosure, and the interaction of insurance contract reporting with financial instrument measurement and jurisdictional endorsement. The study reads the IFRS Foundation's published standard incorporating June 2020 amendments alongside official implementation papers, the International Actuarial Association's technical guidance, open scholarly research and European legal materials. A transparent, deliberately simplified numerical illustration reproduces CSM roll-forwards under favorable and adverse financial scenarios; it does not purport to reproduce a complete IFRS 17 journal-entry system or an insurer's observed experience. The analysis finds that VFA eligibility turns on substantive contractual participation and expected economic variability rather than product labels; VFA CSM is a deferred measure of expected future service profit rather than a complete measure of market value; risk-mitigation decisions and financial-asset classifications determine important reporting asymmetries; and cross-firm comparability requires explicit disclosure of cohort selection, coverage-unit methodology, underlying-item exposure and judgements. These are interpretive conclusions within the existing IFRS 17 architecture, without proposing a new accounting theory.

Keywords: IFRS 17; variable fee approach; VFA; direct participation features; underlying items; contractual service margin; insurance contract services; coverage units; investment-related service; financial guarantees; risk mitigation; IFRS 9; insurance finance income and expenses; annual cohorts; disclosure.

Introduction

Financial reporting for long-duration insurance must account for obligations that combine protection against insured events, prospective investment returns, and ongoing services. Many participating life policies and investment-linked arrangements compensate the insurer through amounts whose economic size changes with the fair value of specified assets or other identified underlying items. Under the general measurement model, changes attributable to financial variables ordinarily follow the finance-result route rather than adjusting unearned future-service profit. The variable fee approach modifies the treatment of the contractual service margin where the insurer's remuneration for services has the requisite direct relationship to underlying items. This is the central accounting distinction established in IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts, particularly paragraphs 45 and B101–B118.

The IFRS Foundation's 2017 Effects Analysis describes VFA as an adaptation of the general model to a contractual obligation understood as the fair value of underlying items less a variable fee for service. The subsequent June 2020 amendments refined insurance-service profit recognition and extended circumstances in which the risk mitigation option could address accounting mismatches. The effective date of IFRS 17 as amended is annual periods beginning on or after January 1, 2023. The original 2017 Effects Analysis discusses an earlier effective-date expectation; any historical date printed there must therefore be read in the light of the 2020 amendment and the current IFRS 17 standard page.

This research addresses three questions. First, what contractual and economic characteristics make an insurance contract directly participating? Second, how do investment returns, nonfinancial assumptions, guarantees and risk mitigation interact with the VFA CSM and its release to profit? Third, what information enables a reader to distinguish a change in future-service profitability from a change in financial market exposure when comparing insurers or reporting jurisdictions? The inquiry is international in scope and deliberately separates IFRS requirements from particular endorsement and implementation choices.

The method is documentary and analytic. Paragraph-level requirements in the 2020 consolidated IFRS 17 text provide the normative benchmark, supplemented by official IASB educational papers. The IFRS 17 CSM Working Party (2021) supplies a detailed actuarial analysis of eligibility, CSM adjustments and coverage-unit difficulties. The International Actuarial Association's IAN 100 is used as nonbinding implementation guidance. Worked numerical cases are derived in this monograph with stated assumptions and independently checkable arithmetic. Institutional examples describe rules and challenges; they are not an estimate of their frequency among actual insurers. Sources were reviewed through November 15, 2026. Any IASB meeting scheduled after that date is a future event, not a completed decision.

Direct Participation Eligibility

Scope and the contractual starting point

IFRS 17 applies to insurance contracts issued, reinsurance held, and, subject to an additional issuer condition, investment contracts with discretionary participation features. Its accounting models include the general measurement model, the premium allocation approach (PAA) where qualifying conditions are met, and the variable fee approach for direct participating contracts. An insurance contract must first meet the definition involving significant insurance risk; the presence of an investment account, fund participation or a variable management charge by itself does not establish an insurance contract. The official IFRS 17 key-terms guidance distinguishes insurance risk, investment components, fulfilment cash flows and the CSM.

The VFA test is specified in IFRS 17 paragraph B101 and elaborated in B102–B109. At inception, contractual terms must identify a pool of underlying items in which the policyholder participates; the entity must expect to pay the policyholder a substantial share of those items' fair value returns; and a substantial proportion of changes in policyholder amounts must be expected to vary with changes in their fair value. Each condition matters. A policy may credit returns linked to a fund yet contain a discretionary crediting mechanism that fails the required contractual connection. Alternatively, it may specify the pool but assign such a small portion of returns to the policyholder that the economic test fails. The IFRS Foundation's reinsurance guide restates the three conditions in its explanation of VFA.

The assessment is made using expectations at inception. Under paragraph B102 the classification generally remains fixed afterward, subject to the treatment of qualifying contract modifications. Consequently, subsequent market stress or a change in asset allocation does not automatically justify migrating a group between the VFA and the general model. Classification is an accounting conclusion about rights, expectations and the specified underlying-item relationship at inception. The CSM Working Party's eligibility discussion illustrates why conventional unit-linked and with-profits product labels are inadequate substitutes for examining the contract.

What constitutes a clearly identified pool?

Underlying items may include a pool of assets or other identifiable elements used to establish amounts payable to policyholders. Contractual identification can arise from legally enforceable terms and incorporated rules, including relevant statutory or participating-fund mechanisms; the test requires the investor to be able to identify what the participation relates to. The insurer need not necessarily hold the underlying items, because the obligation is defined by the contractual reference, although whether it holds them matters later for presentation of insurance finance income and expenses.

A reference to management's future discretionary choice of a return, with no clearly identified underlying items, has a different economic and accounting structure from a contractual promise to pass through a substantial share of specified returns. The insurer may manage identical financial assets in either case, while only one set of contractual rights satisfies the direct participation test. Eligibility depends on the architecture of the policyholder obligation, not merely on the asset portfolio that backs it. The KPMG IFRS 17 analysis explains that underlying items can take different forms but must be contractually identifiable.

"Substantial" is purpose-sensitive rather than a universal numerical percentage. Paragraph B107 calls for evaluating expected participation and variability over the contract's duration and across a range of scenarios. A single favorable return or a single-year allocation is insufficient. Minimum benefits, caps, smoothing, surrender provisions, death benefits and policyholder options can materially modify the sensitivity of payable amounts to changes in underlying items. The robust test asks how much of the economic variability is transferred to the policyholder under plausible paths, considering the contract as written.

Contrasting illustrative contracts

Consider Contract A, which specifies a segregated fund as an underlying pool and provides that the policyholder receives 85 percent of fair value returns on that fund, subject to an insurance death benefit. Suppose actuarial projections over the entire duration and realistic outcomes show that fair value returns explain a substantial proportion of changes in the policyholder's payout. All three VFA conditions may be met. The 85 percent is an illustrative contractual fact; IFRS 17 supplies no universal 85 percent safe harbor.

Contract B specifies the same fund as an investment benchmark but reserves complete discretion to determine periodic bonuses without a binding entitlement to a substantial share of that pool's fair value returns. Economic asset backing alone cannot supply the missing contractual condition. Contract C clearly identifies a pool but protects the policyholder through a dominant fixed guarantee such that the amount payable changes little when the fund value changes over a wide range of scenarios. It requires a careful assessment of the expected variability tests; an asserted investment link cannot override their substantive outcome.

The analytical implication is material. Two economically similar investment operations can produce different CSM paths because their policyholder obligations differ. An insurer's financial reporting classification should therefore be documented with specimen contractual clauses, description of the pool, modeled proportions across scenarios and an assessment at inception. The IASB's implementation materials provide the broader context for consistent application. Documenting the eligibility evidence strengthens both auditability and comparability.

Unit of account, groups and reinsurance

VFA operates within IFRS 17's grouping requirements. Contracts are assigned to portfolios of similar risks managed together, then divided into specified profitability categories and issuance cohorts, subject to applicable requirements and jurisdiction-specific exceptions. A single policy cannot be assessed in isolation for every subsequent accounting outcome once it is included in an appropriately constituted group. Group-level CSM reflects offsets among contracts permitted by the grouping rules and prevents a discretionary aggregation of all profitable and onerous business.

Direct participation in underlying items is distinct from the treatment of reinsurance held. Reinsurance issued to protect a participating portfolio does not ordinarily become a VFA contract simply because its underlying insurance contracts qualify. IFRS 17 applies separate reinsurance-contract accounting. The official reinsurance contracts pocket guide makes this limitation explicit. This distinction becomes important when the insurer uses reinsurance as an eligible financial-risk mitigant.

Underlying Items and Variable Fees

Economic identity of the fee

The VFA conceptualizes the issuer's obligation in a direct participating contract as the value of underlying items payable to policyholders less the variable fee retained for services. Paragraph B104 identifies the fee as the entity's share of the fair value of underlying items minus fulfilment cash flows that do not vary based on underlying-item returns. This description should be read as a financial-reporting decomposition of the insurance obligation, not as evidence that every identifiable insurer charge equals accounting profit or that the assets are always legally held on policyholders' behalf.

A stylized expression makes the decomposition visible. Let U denote the fair value of the contractually identified underlying items; let a be the insurer's contractual share of their change, under a simple linear participation rule; let N denote the discounted expected fulfilment outflows other than the policyholder share of U; and let F denote the variable fee attributable to future services. In an illustrative proportional case, F = aU − N, with changes analyzed according to IFRS 17's subsequent-measurement rules. This notation describes a contractual example. It is not a new general accounting model and does not replace the complete measurement of fulfilment cash flows, discounting, risk adjustment and the CSM required by IFRS 17.

The economic sensitivity of the fee may vary by state. If a policyholder has a minimum guaranteed accumulation value G, an oversimplified payout can be represented as max((1 − a)U, G). As U falls below the guarantee threshold, the policyholder's participation sensitivity decreases and the guarantee acquires greater value. The guarantee's measurement under IFRS 17 depends on contractual details, options, discounting and stochastic scenarios, but this elementary payoff explains why a fee based on underlying values and an embedded financial guarantee may move in opposing directions. The 2017 Effects Analysis discusses the relation between investment-linked returns, variable fees and financial guarantees.

Fair values, cash flows and ownership

The VFA uses the fair value of underlying items in its fee-related CSM adjustments. The underlying items may be actual held assets, a specified pool or another qualifying reference; the holding of assets is not itself the eligibility condition. Insurers nonetheless report investment assets under their applicable standards, principally IFRS 9 Financial Instruments for financial instruments within its scope. An underlying item measured through fair value changes in profit or loss can yield a different presentation pattern from one classified and measured otherwise. Identical VFA liability sensitivities therefore need not generate identical net profit or loss paths.

A financial-reporting analysis must track four linked objects separately: the policyholder's entitlement; the insurer's contractual fee and guarantees; the insurer's actual held investments and hedges; and the accounting measurements and presentation routes applicable to those assets. The fourth object is fundamental. Portfolio managers may achieve an effective economic hedge while separate IFRS 17 and IFRS 9 recognition rules create temporal accounting mismatches. In the reverse case, amounts may look aligned in a single statement even though duration, convexity, liquidity or guarantee exposures remain material.

The treatment of changes in fulfilment cash flows is also crucial. They include future premiums, benefits, directly attributable expenses, discounting and a risk adjustment for nonfinancial risk, consistently with contract boundaries. Subsequent adjustments depend on whether they relate to future service, current or past service, and the specified financial-risk effects. The official glossary of IFRS 17 terms provides a concise orientation, while the detailed IFRS 17 requirements determine the actual accounting.

Fair value changes and what CSM means

The CSM is an unearned profit component released as the insurer provides contract services. It cannot be read as the present value of all shareholder cash flows, the market capitalization of an insurer or a standalone solvency measure. The CSM excludes recognized losses on onerous groups, is affected by grouping, and reflects accounting allocation across future services. Distinct current-period results and insurance finance effects can therefore change total reported income independently of the closing CSM.

Actuarial literature reinforces the distinction between an accounting schedule and an economic valuation. Palmborg, Lindholm, and Lindskog (2021) develop a mathematical interpretation of IFRS 17 measurement and financial performance, demonstrating the computational demands of risk-based accounting. Their numerical methods concern a deliberately specified insurance setting and should not be treated as empirical validation of every VFA product. The broader insight is that measurement and profit-recognition algorithms answer related but different questions.

CSM Adjustments for Market Changes

The subsequent-measurement principle

At initial recognition, profitable groups have a CSM that prevents recognition of expected future service profit as a day-one gain. VFA generally shares the foundational fulfilment-cash-flow machinery with the general measurement model. Divergence appears in subsequent CSM adjustments. Paragraph 45 of IFRS 17 specifies the VFA roll-forward, while B110–B118 explain adjustments reflecting changes in the variable fee. The consolidated standard text is the controlling normative source.

In broad terms, VFA CSM adjusts for the entity's share of changes in the fair value of underlying items and for changes in fulfilment cash flows that relate to future service, including some financial-risk effects that would be recognized differently under the general model. Certain changes attributable to current or past service bypass the CSM. The effect of the time value of money and financial risks not arising from underlying items, including financial guarantees, is addressed in B113. The entity may combine certain adjustments under B114; it must nevertheless substantiate their measurement and classification.

Paragraphs B115–B118 establish a specific risk mitigation option in qualifying circumstances. A VFA roll-forward is therefore contingent not only on investment performance and prospective benefits but also on choices supported by documented risk-management objectives and eligible instruments. The CSM must be tested for recoverability as an unearned positive amount: negative future-service profitability beyond the available CSM is recognized as a loss and contributes to a loss component. The CSM Working Party (2021) provides detailed comparisons of general-model and VFA movements and the handling of loss components.

A transparent accounting illustration

The following exercise isolates a prospective fee adjustment and coverage-unit release for one simplified group during a single reporting period. All amounts are fictional currency units. The exercise is an intentionally partial CSM bridge, not a complete IFRS 17 financial-statement example. Assume an opening CSM of 80, an illustrative 15 percent entity share of movements in an identified pool, and no new contracts, currency effects or other CSM movements. Also assume that the market-related fee changes and prospective nonfinancial cash-flow changes presented below have been assessed as relating to future service, and that no risk mitigation option is exercised. The figures for guarantees represent an adverse change in the effect of financial risk that otherwise adjusts VFA CSM.

CSM movement Favorable market Moderate decline Severe decline
Opening CSM 80.0 80.0 80.0
Change in fair value of underlying items +120.0 −120.0 −500.0
Entity share of underlying-item change, 15% +18.0 −18.0 −75.0
Adverse change in future nonfinancial fulfilment cash flows −11.0 −12.0 −20.0
Adverse change in financial-guarantee effect −9.0 −25.0 −35.0
Prospective CSM before floor and service allocation 78.0 25.0 −50.0
Immediate loss on adverse excess 0.0 0.0 50.0
Available CSM after floor 78.0 25.0 0.0
Illustrative current-period coverage units 40 40 40
Illustrative future coverage units 60 60 60
CSM allocated to current service 31.2 10.0 0.0
Closing CSM 46.8 15.0 0.0

For the favorable scenario, the pre-allocation CSM is 80 + 0.15 × 120 − 11 − 9 = 78. The assumed current-service proportion is 40/(40 + 60) = 0.40. Profit recognized through the CSM release is 78 × 0.40 = 31.2, leaving 46.8. For the moderate decline, 80 − 18 − 12 − 25 = 25; 25 × 0.40 = 10, leaving 15. For the severe decline, 80 − 75 − 20 − 35 = −50. The CSM is exhausted and a 50 loss is recognized under the assumed all-future-service classification, leaving no CSM to release. The standard additionally requires loss-component measurement, subsequent allocation and reversal rules that a single bridge does not represent.

This table is reproducible directly from its assumptions. It does not assume that policyholders receive the entire asset gain, that a recognized insurer investment asset changes by exactly the underlying reference amount, or that the change in reported profit equals the CSM movement. A complete journal-entry illustration would separately include asset measurement, insurance finance income or expenses, current-period insurance services, the total fulfilment-cash-flow movement, and appropriate financial-statement classification. The IFRS Foundation's 2020 project summary explains the intended relationship between VFA profit recognition and services.

Interpretation of the stress cases

The favorable market increases the insurer's future variable fee while the assumed adverse cash-flow and guarantee changes partly offset it. Recognition of 31.2 of service profit reflects the hypothesized service delivery; the market appreciation itself is not the measure of service rendered in the current period. In the moderate decline the available expected future-service profit shrinks substantially, and the same 40 percent service allocation releases only 10. In the severe decline the CSM cannot absorb the negative changes and a loss must be recognized immediately under the stated assumptions.

The table isolates a central analytical fact: identical current-period service patterns can produce very different CSM releases because the size of the pool of unearned expected future profit is remeasured. Conversely, equal closing CSM values can arise from different combinations of investment performance, financial guarantees, nonfinancial assumptions and releases. A closing balance is therefore an aggregate outcome requiring a reconciliation to be interpretable.

Ordering, sign conventions and actuarial controls

CSM accounting requires a defined sign convention. A favorable change in the entity's fee is shown as a positive CSM adjustment; an increase in expected future outflows or guarantee burden is shown as a negative adjustment. Actual reporting systems may use signed liability cash flows and different ledger conventions, but the economic mapping must be consistent. For a group of contracts, new business, interest accretion where relevant, movements in fulfilment cash flows, currency changes, losses, reversals and service allocation must be reconciled in the applicable sequence.

The VFA should not be mechanically described as applying current discount rates to every possible CSM component in precisely the same way as the general model. Paragraph-level differences matter. The IASB standard paragraphs B110–B118 distinguish the changes associated with the underlying-item share and changes in cash flows that do or do not relate directly to those items. The CSM Working Party's subsequent-measurement study also notes implementation challenges in ordering adjustments and interpreting experience variances.

Financial model governance follows from this structure. The insurer should preserve data lineage from underlying-item valuations to the participating formula; quantify the effect of guarantees under consistent scenarios; label each change by future versus current or past service; monitor the effect of assumptions about policyholder behavior; and reconcile CSM to both actuarial cash-flow projections and general-ledger outputs. An unexplained residual must be treated as a control failure rather than assigned reflexively to a generic market-change bucket.

Guarantees and Risk Mitigation

Financial guarantees within VFA

Many participating contracts contain guaranteed minimum payments, surrender values, minimum crediting rates or options. These features can materially alter the sensitivity of future obligations to underlying-item performance. A guarantee with a floor becomes more expensive when adverse market movements make it more likely to bind; changes in the expected value of future guarantee payments can move in the opposite direction from the insurer's share of underlying returns. VFA requires recognition of applicable effects of financial risk on future service under paragraphs B113 and B115–B118.

The guarantee must be modeled over plausible market scenarios, including correlations among asset returns, interest rates, policyholder actions and mortality where relevant. A deterministic comparison of today's fund value and guaranteed amount may omit the time value of the option. Cash-flow projections should recognize contract boundaries and distinguish financial risks from the risk adjustment for nonfinancial risk. This distinction is necessary because the IFRS 17 risk adjustment addresses compensation for bearing nonfinancial risk, not a generic premium for all market volatility.

A simple option-like payoff, max(G − (1 − a)U, 0), shows how an otherwise directly participating contract can contain an additional guarantee liability. It is a pedagogical representation of a terminal top-up and omits path dependence, cash-flow timing, withdrawal behavior, discounting and insurance events. It cannot be used as a stand-alone IFRS 17 valuation. The IFRS 17 consolidated requirements govern classification of the contractual promise and the relevant cash flows.

The risk mitigation option

Without a specific exception, some movements in the effect of financial risk on future services would adjust the VFA CSM while movements in derivatives used to hedge that risk would be recognized in current profit or loss. The economic protection might work, yet the accounting results could show an asymmetric timing effect. IFRS 17's risk mitigation option permits a qualifying entity, to the extent of designated hedged financial risk, to recognize certain changes in profit or loss instead of adjusting the CSM.

The option is conditional. Paragraph B116 requires a previously documented risk-management objective and strategy, an economic offset between the insurance contract and the eligible hedging instrument, and an assessment that credit risk does not dominate that offset. Eligibility of hedging instruments and risk types depends on the specific provision. In the amended standard, derivatives and reinsurance contracts held are eligible for specified risks, and nonderivative instruments measured at fair value through profit or loss are eligible for the financial-risk effect described in B113(b). The 2020 amendment summary describes the extension of the risk mitigation option, and the IASB's February 2020 analysis explains the rationale.

The option is bounded by the documented economic relationship. It cannot be treated as a general right to move any unfavorable financial change out of CSM or to claim a hedge retrospectively after observing results. Its application affects income timing and must be supported by consistent designation, monitoring, eligible instruments, and clear treatment of changes in risk-management practice. In the simplified CSM table above no option was applied, so the full assumed guarantee changes were shown as CSM movements. Were some of those risks qualifyingly mitigated, the illustrative bridge would need to remove the specified elected adjustment and report its current-period profit-or-loss consequences separately.

A two-ledger comparison

Suppose a financial guarantee becomes 25 more burdensome under an adverse financial scenario. A perfectly simplified hedge also increases in fair value by 25. Under VFA without the risk mitigation option, the future-service guarantee effect may reduce CSM by 25 while the hedge's gain is recognized currently under the relevant financial instrument accounting. The two amounts are economically offsetting in this stylized illustration but appear in different accounting components. When the risk mitigation option applies to the eligible extent and its requirements are met, the guarantee's financial-risk effect can also be recognized in profit or loss, potentially aligning its timing with the hedge gain.

The example is not a full proof of a zero net income effect: actual hedge relationships include basis risk, valuation conventions, taxation, settlement schedules, transaction costs and nonfinancial cash-flow interactions. Moreover, economic offset under IFRS 17 does not automatically mean hedge accounting under IFRS 9, nor does one accounting standard override the other's instrument measurement criteria. The IASB May 2020 sweep paper analyzes the interaction between the VFA risk mitigation option and the OCI presentation choice.

Reinsurance and residual exposures

Reinsurance held may mitigate relevant risks associated with a VFA portfolio even though the reinsurance contract itself is measured under its own IFRS 17 requirements. Economically valuable protection and accounting-mismatch reduction are separate outcomes. A reinsurance arrangement may reduce mortality or longevity risk without satisfying the specific conditions for the financial-risk mitigation option. Conversely, a qualifying financial-risk reinsurance arrangement may alter the VFA recognition of the mitigated effect while the reinsurance asset follows separate measurement and presentation requirements.

Insurers should document which risks are covered, the measurement basis of the reinsurance, contract boundaries, counterparty risk, basis risk and the extent of offset. The IFRS Foundation's reinsurance guide is explicit about the distinct accounting treatment. This prevents a category error in which participation of original policyholders in assets is assumed to transfer unchanged into the structure of the reinsurance contract.

VFA Reporting and Disclosure

Recognition, presentation and reconciliations

IFRS 17 requires reporting of insurance service results separately from insurance finance income or expenses. Insurance revenue excludes receipts that are investment components, and insurance service expenses exclude repayments of investment components. A participating policy's gross premium or fund contribution is therefore not automatically insurance revenue. Reporting requires analysis of which elements constitute insurance service and how the corresponding service revenue is derived.

A reader of a VFA insurer needs a reconciliation of the opening and closing CSM that distinguishes new business, the insurer's share of underlying-item movements, changes in prospective fulfilment cash flows, financial-risk effects, losses and reversals where relevant, currency effects and the amount recognized for service delivered. Appropriate disclosures also include significant judgments, financial and nonfinancial risk sensitivities, remaining coverage, and the nature and extent of risks. IFRS 17 paragraphs 93–132 provide the controlling framework; the IFRS Foundation's presentation overview summarizes its objectives.

The quality of a reconciliation depends on traceability. Aggregated descriptions such as "assumption changes" can hide important distinctions between fund returns, expense projections, guarantees and policyholder behavior. A useful CSM bridge should separate material drivers in a way appropriate to the insurer's contracts and materiality judgments. This is a scholarly recommendation about decision-useful explanation, not a proposed addition to IFRS 17's mandatory line-item taxonomy.

The International Actuarial Association's IAN 100 treats presentation and disclosure as integral to financial reporting of insurance contracts. It is an educational resource. The requirements remain those of the adopted IFRS Standards, and reporting-period changes or jurisdictional endorsements can affect the applicable legal texts.

Financial assets and OCI interactions

For VFA contracts, the accounting for underlying financial assets under IFRS 9 can affect where corresponding returns appear. IFRS 17 permits a disaggregation of insurance finance income or expenses between profit or loss and other comprehensive income (OCI) subject to the applicable accounting policy and contractual conditions. The standard distinguishes circumstances in which the entity holds underlying items from other circumstances; paragraph 89 addresses the current-period book-yield approach when its conditions are met. The IASB's May 2020 discussion explains the risk of mismatches arising when this presentation route is combined with the risk mitigation option.

Financial-statement users should avoid assuming that a small observed net profit-or-loss movement proves the absence of market risk. OCI accumulation, different asset classifications, the use of derivatives, the future-service CSM treatment and economic exposures can all influence reported line items. An analytical comparison should reconcile the underlying-item return, insurer-share change, movements in guarantees, hedge results and each accounting presentation route. This is especially important when comparing investment-linked insurers, traditional participating life business and insurers with substantial held-to-collect bond portfolios.

European annual cohorts and international comparability

The international standard's requirement to group contracts into annual cohorts has generated debate for intergenerationally mutualized and cash-flow-matched insurance portfolios. The European Union's historic Commission Regulation 2021/2036 provided an optional, specified annual-cohort exemption for certain contracts. That act was subsequently replaced as part of the EU's restated IFRS-adoption legislation; the operative legal framework must be checked in the EU Regulation 2023/1803 framework and its amendments and consolidated versions. The distinction between the legal instrument that established an exemption and a later consolidated adopting act matters for correctly dating and attributing the rule.

The exemption concerns the unit of account and its aggregation consequences. It does not replace the paragraph B101 VFA eligibility test. The financial reporting effect is nonetheless potentially consequential because annual group boundaries influence how profitable and onerous cohorts and their CSM movements are identified. The EU's exception creates a comparability qualification between financial statements applying the IASB-issued requirements without modification and those using the EU-permitted relief where applicable.

On September 25, 2026, EFRAG's recommendation on the exemption review urged the European Commission to postpone reconsideration of the exemption until the IASB's post-implementation review could inform it. The underlying legal review deadline was then December 31, 2027; EFRAG's recommendation is a request, not an amendment of law. As of the research cutoff, the IASB November 2026 meeting agenda lists a paper concerning initiation of the IFRS 17 post-implementation review for a meeting on November 17–19, 2026. The meeting had not yet occurred on November 15, and this monograph makes no claim that its proposed decisions were adopted.

IFRS 18 and future reporting presentation

IFRS 18 Presentation and Disclosure in Financial Statements is effective for annual reporting periods beginning on or after January 1, 2027, with earlier application permitted. It introduces changes to general financial statement presentation, including defined subtotals and disclosures regarding management-defined performance measures, while also making consequential amendments to other standards. For a 2026 VFA study, IFRS 18 is a forward-looking presentation development, not a blanket assertion that the new requirements were already mandatory in 2026. Insurers must assess how the new reporting presentation requirements interact with IFRS 17's specific insurance revenue, service-result and finance-result requirements.

The connection among IFRS 17, IFRS 9 and IFRS 18 illustrates an important institutional point: a liability measurement model cannot by itself establish comparability of overall insurer performance. Comparability depends on the measurement and presentation of assets, the insurance contract service margin and the financial statements in which they appear. The IFRS 9 standard overview is a useful complement when examining the reporting of held financial instruments.

Evidence and boundaries of empirical inference

The scientific literature contributes critical evaluation of accounting consequences and standard-setting. Palmborg, Lindholm, and Lindskog (2021) construct actuarial valuation and reporting algorithms, but their numerical analysis explicitly focuses on cash flows independent of financial asset values; it does not validate a stochastic VFA implementation. The CSM Working Party (2021) addresses participating business directly but is a technical interpretive study, not a representative population estimate. Research on participation in the IFRS 17 due process analyzes institutional consultation and legitimacy, illuminating why standard development and implementation remain contested. None of these works justifies claiming a statistically measured VFA profitability effect across all international insurers.

An adequate future empirical project would identify companies using VFA, classify products and jurisdictions, control for asset allocation and reporting elections, extract CSM reconciliations and use consistently defined pre/post observations. Changes caused by interest-rate shocks, first-time adoption, market movements, mergers, actuarial assumptions or presentation elections must be distinguished before assigning any effect to VFA. This monograph does not report new company-level data, cross-country causal estimates or a meta-analysis. It provides a source-grounded accounting interpretation and transparent mathematical tests.

Integrated analytical findings

The eligibility boundary operates through contractual rights and expected variability. The measurement boundary operates through future-service attribution. The presentation boundary operates through asset accounting, insurance finance reporting and jurisdictional rules. Each boundary is specified by existing law or accounting standards, yet their interaction explains why superficially similar participating products may show different financial performance.

A useful accounting comparison therefore asks whether two insurers have equivalent policyholder participation promises; whether they use equivalent contract-grouping criteria; whether their CSM adjustments reflect equivalent future-service estimates; whether service units are comparable; and how guarantees and risk mitigation elections have been applied. Without this information, a comparison of closing CSM or insurance service profit may conflate contractual economics with accounting allocation choices.

The original contribution of this dossier is the synthesis of these three pre-existing accounting boundaries into a source-based comparative reading, together with a reproducible CSM stress illustration and the consequent reporting questions. It is not presented as a new theory, doctrine, model or proprietary measurement method. Its value lies in identifying the precise sources of divergences that can be investigated using actual insurer disclosures.

Conclusion

The variable fee approach gives accounting form to the contractually defined relationship between policyholder participation in underlying items and the insurer's remuneration for future insurance contract services. IFRS 17 makes VFA eligibility conditional on a clearly specified underlying-item pool, a substantial expected policyholder share of fair value returns and substantial expected variability of policyholder amounts with those returns. These conditions are assessed at inception and require substantive contractual evidence. Neither a participating product name nor the existence of segregated assets establishes eligibility alone.

Under VFA, subsequent CSM reflects changes in the expected variable fee and relevant future-service fulfilment cash flows, including specified financial-risk effects. The simplified calculations in this monograph show how the same initial CSM and coverage-unit pattern produce sharply different service-profit releases after changes in underlying returns, future cash flows and guarantees. Severe adverse changes can exhaust expected future-service profit and trigger immediate loss recognition. Coverage units determine how the remaining CSM is recognized as services are provided; their construction requires documented judgment about insurance and investment-related benefits.

Financial guarantees and hedges create an additional layer of interaction. The risk mitigation option can reduce some accounting mismatches when its exact documentation, economic-offset and instrument requirements are satisfied. The insurer's held assets remain subject to their own classification and measurement. This makes an explicit reconciliation across underlying-item returns, financial-risk effects, CSM movements, hedge outcomes and insurance finance presentation essential for interpreting reported results.

International comparability also depends on the grouping and disclosure regime. The EU's specified annual-cohort exemption affects aggregation while leaving core VFA eligibility criteria intact. IFRS 18's 2027 effective date creates a further presentation context without altering the status of the 2026 reporting period. Ongoing IASB review activity is a matter for future monitoring, not a basis for assigning conclusions to meetings not yet held.

The research conclusion is that VFA provides a coherent accounting treatment of a variable fee for future services, while its observable financial outcomes remain jointly shaped by contractual design, actuarial assumptions, financial markets, accounting elections and disclosure practices. A well-supported interpretation requires testing each of these dimensions separately and reconnecting them through the entity's actual contracts and reconciliations. The documented numerical examples and cross-source analysis meet that objective within the evidence available as of November 15, 2026. No independent external peer review or empirical validation is claimed.

References

  • International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). (2020). IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts, incorporating the June 2020 amendments. IFRS Foundation. Official standard text.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2026, accessed November 15). IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts: Issued standard and standard history. Standards overview.

  • International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). (2017). IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts: Effects Analysis. IFRS Foundation. Effects Analysis.

  • International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). (2020). Amendments to IFRS 17: Project Summary and Feedback Statement. IFRS Foundation. Project summary.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2020). IFRS 17 pocket guide on reinsurance contracts held. Implementation guide.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2018). IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts: Key terms. Terminology page.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2026, accessed November 15). IFRS 17 supporting material. Implementation resource index.

  • IFRS 17 Transition Resource Group / IASB staff. (2018, May). Determining the quantity of benefits for identifying coverage units, Agenda Paper 5. IFRS Foundation. Coverage-units paper.

  • International Actuarial Association (IAA). (2021, August 31). International Actuarial Note 100: Application of IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts. IAN 100.

  • Yousuf, W., Stansfield, J., Malde, K., Mirin, N., Walton, R., Thorpe, B., Thorpe, J., Iftode, C., Tan, L., Dyble, R., Pelsser, A., Ghosh, A., Qin, W., Berry, T., & Er, C. (2021). The IFRS 17 contractual service margin: A life insurance perspective. British Actuarial Journal, 26, e2. (IFRS 17 CSM Working Party.) https://doi.org/10.1017/S1357321721000015.

  • Palmborg, L., Lindholm, M., & Lindskog, F. (2021). Financial position and performance in IFRS 17. Scandinavian Actuarial Journal, 2021(3), 171–197. https://doi.org/10.1080/03461238.2020.1823464.

  • Arce, M., Giner, B., & Taleb, M. A. (2023). Due process as a legitimating mechanism: Participation and responsiveness in the development of IFRS 17: Insurance contracts. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 42(6), 107150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2023.107150.

  • KPMG IFRG Limited. (2020). First Impressions: IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts (2020 edition), Chapter 15: Direct participating contracts. Technical commentary.

  • International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) staff. (2020, February). Applicability of the risk mitigation option—Non-derivative financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss, Agenda Paper 2C. IFRS Foundation. Staff paper.

  • International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) staff. (2020, May). Amendments to IFRS 17: Sweep issues, Agenda Paper 2. IFRS Foundation. Staff paper.

  • European Commission. (2021). Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/2036 of 19 November 2021, Official Journal L 416, 23 November 2021, pp. 3–79; historic instrument superseded by later adoption legislation. EUR-Lex original act.

  • European Commission. (2023). Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/1803 of 13 September 2023 adopting certain international accounting standards, Official Journal L 237, 26 September 2023, pp. 1–992; as subsequently amended. EUR-Lex adopting act.

  • European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG). (2026, September 25). EFRAG asks the European Commission to delay the IFRS 17 annual cohort exemption review. EFRAG news release.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2026, accessed November 15). IFRS 9 Financial Instruments. Issued-standard page.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2026, accessed November 15). IFRS 18 Presentation and Disclosure in Financial Statements. Issued-standard page.

  • IFRS Foundation. (2026). International Accounting Standards Board meeting, November 17–19, 2026: Agenda, including paper AP8A on initiation of the IFRS 17 post-implementation review. Meeting agenda.