Insurance by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Insurance and Risk Science

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Insurer Key Function Holder Fit and Proper Assessments

Abstract. Fit and proper assessment is a continuing prudential judgment about whether a person can exercise a particular insurance governance or control responsibility competently and with integrity. This study examines the persons covered, evidentiary criteria, institutional allocation of assessment responsibility, collective board competence, initial appointments, continuing reassessment, supervisory intervention and removal. Its method is comparative doctrinal analysis of international supervisory standards and selected national arrangements, supplemented by bounded review of insurer-governance research and a historical supervisory assessment. The comparison distinguishes the International Association of Insurance Supervisors (IAIS) benchmark from European Union legislation, the United Kingdom's approval and certification arrangements, Australian prudential requirements, Canadian background-check guidance and a California governance disclosure example. Suitability is analyzed in relation to the distribution of knowledge, organizational authority and changing risk exposures. The principal conclusion is that credible assessment connects demonstrated role capability and integrity with an institutional capacity to challenge decisions, identify adverse changes and respond before deficiencies endanger policyholders. Collective competence enlarges institutional capacity but cannot cure an individually disqualifying deficiency. Documentary completeness is a necessary evidentiary condition; operational effectiveness calls for independent observation of decision processes and response to emerging risks. Available empirical literature provides contingent associations rather than a causal estimate of the effectiveness of fit and proper regulation. The original contribution is an integrated interpretation of these distinctions and their implications for insurance supervision.

Keywords: Insurance governance; fit and proper assessment; suitability of persons; control functions; actuarial function; supervisory approval; collective competence; integrity; prudential regulation; policyholder protection; continuing assessment.

Introduction

An insurer accepts obligations whose economic consequences frequently become observable years after the decisions that created them. Pricing choices become evident in loss experience, investment decisions in market and liquidity shocks, and weaknesses in reserving in the gradual revision of liabilities. The people responsible for identifying these developments exercise judgment over contingent claims and incomplete information. Prudential governance therefore includes the quality of those judgments and the institutional arrangements through which weaknesses become visible and correctable.

Fit and proper assessment addresses a question that neither minimum capital requirements nor commercial recruitment can settle by themselves: whether the holder of a legally significant position possesses the capability and integrity needed to discharge that position. The answer depends on the activities of the insurer, the responsibilities of the person and the conditions under which the person can actually perform. A qualified actuary may have the technical knowledge necessary to review reserves but lack experience with the insurer's particular long-duration guarantees. A respected executive may be an unsuitable internal audit leader if self-review compromises independent assurance. An experienced director may face a material commitment problem when simultaneously serving on several boards.

These examples are hypothetical. They illustrate why professional merit, formal authority and prudent exercise of authority require distinct examination. A suitability decision is directed at a concrete role, at a specified institution and at a particular point in time. Subsequent changes can alter the judgment even when an individual's historical qualifications remain the same.

Research questions and scope

The first question concerns the substantive evidence required to establish competence and integrity. The second concerns the relationship between the suitability of individual officeholders and the combined capabilities of a board. The third concerns how an insurer and its supervisor detect and address changes after appointment. The study also asks which features of different regulatory systems are functionally comparable and what evidence would be necessary to establish their effectiveness.

The focus is on people who effectively direct an insurer or lead material control functions. Significant owners enter the analysis only to clarify the boundary of regulated categories. Broker licensing, general hiring practice, product suitability for customers and shareholder change-of-control approvals are separate research subjects. Prudential soundness and conduct outcomes enter as consequences of the allocation of governance authority.

Research method

This is a qualitative comparison organized around regulated population, suitability criteria, evidence, decision responsibility, timing, continuing monitoring and corrective action. The 2024 IAIS standard provides the common reference point. The EU comparison examines the January 17, 2025 consolidated directive and the original delegated regulation's relevant provision, with attention to the subsequent legislative calendar. The UK comparison examines the published supervisory descriptions of approval and certification and the 2026 reform sequence. Australia supplies a more prescriptive example; Canadian and California instruments illustrate particular background-check and disclosure arrangements.

The legal sources are differentiated by their authority. International supervisory standards establish a benchmark; directives, regulations and domestic prudential instruments have distinct legal effects; administrative guidance supplies expectations and interpretations; scholarly articles describe empirical associations. The research does not infer uniform domestic enforcement or substitute for jurisdiction-specific legal advice. The documentary cutoff is November 19, 2026. Selected sources and passages were examined rather than every national implementing instrument. The literature review is targeted and does not constitute a systematic review or original statistical estimation.

Definitions and regulated person categories

The prudential meaning of suitability

Suitability combines role-specific professional capacity with the reliability needed to exercise financial authority. The institutional purpose is prospective: a decision about the allocation or continuation of responsibilities. Past experience and conduct are relevant because they provide observable evidence bearing on that decision. Their significance depends on recency, circumstances, verification and relevance.

The IAIS (2024) ICP 5 on suitability identifies board members, senior management, key persons in control functions and significant owners within the supervisory perimeter. Competence and integrity are central for officeholders; financial soundness and integrity have particular significance for significant owners. The breadth of this international benchmark should not be confused with an identical statutory population in every jurisdiction.

Four distinctions follow. Board members oversee the overall strategic direction and prudent governance of an entity. Senior management organizes and implements its operations. Key control personnel lead functions that identify, evaluate or provide assurance about risks and compliance. Significant owners exercise influence through ownership and capital relationships. One person may occupy overlapping categories, but each covered responsibility requires its own assessment of relevance and conflicts.

The practical boundary should reflect actual influence. A title may conceal a function that has become material through delegation, committee responsibilities or control of information. Conversely, a technical specialist may contribute crucial analysis while another person retains authority and accountability for the conclusions delivered to the board. Identifying the relevant person therefore requires examination of responsibility maps, delegations, employment arrangements, reporting lines and actual decision rights.

Control functions in the insurance enterprise

Risk management, compliance, actuarial oversight and internal audit perform different kinds of governance work. Risk management integrates exposure information and challenges the relationship between strategy and risk capacity. Compliance interprets obligations and examines whether operations adhere to them. Actuarial oversight provides technical assessments of liabilities, assumptions and insurance risks. Internal audit evaluates the design and operation of governance and control arrangements with appropriate independence.

Their respective competence requirements arise from the information they must assess and the decisions they influence. A risk leader must connect underwriting, market, counterparty and operational exposures. A compliance leader must understand obligations and the implementation constraints of business processes. An actuarial leader must recognize uncertainty in models, data and assumptions. An audit leader must be able to determine whether evidence is sufficient and whether the assurance process has been compromised.

These descriptions are analytical illustrations of role content. Actual duties vary with local law, the insurance business and the internal allocation of accountability. The functions may have different formal labels and structures across jurisdictions. Some arrangements place technical work with a subsidiary or external provider. The key analytical question is which person determines the quality of the function's output and can escalate concerns to the bodies empowered to act.

Regulatory perimeter and delegation

Australia's CPS 520 responsible-person perimeter (APRA, 2018) differentiates responsible persons by type of regulated entity and can include individuals working as contractors or within another entity. This illustrates why the regulated role cannot always be identified through payroll records alone. A shared actuarial service may employ the people who perform calculations in a central office while a locally accountable officer retains responsibility for their suitability and use.

The significance of a function also depends on time. A person initially appointed to oversee a modest portfolio may later gain decision responsibility for acquisitions, delegated underwriting or an internal model. A role inventory that records only position names may miss the change. Maintaining a current description of responsibilities allows selection and ongoing monitoring to address material changes in authority rather than treating appointments as permanent classifications.

Insurance-specific consequences

Insurance governance has a distinctive intertemporal dimension. A claimant may have no practical opportunity to observe the quality of reserving, hedge management or reinsurance recoverability when purchasing a policy. The consequences of inadequate oversight may emerge after the premium has been paid and after the individuals responsible have changed positions. This creates an institutional need for verifiable continuity in governance records.

For a long-tail insurer, a control leader's capability to scrutinize claims trends and uncertainty in ultimate loss estimates may be essential. For a life insurer with guarantees, expertise in asset-liability mismatch, options and lapse behavior may be especially significant. For a reinsurer, concentration and aggregation across cedants can be central. These different contexts demonstrate why universal categories of fitness must be interpreted through specific decision responsibilities.

Competence, integrity and governance expectations

Competence as demonstrated capacity

Competence consists of the knowledge, experience, judgment and capacity necessary to exercise the assigned responsibilities. Examination should distinguish formal eligibility credentials from the ability to use technical knowledge under the conditions of the role. A professional certificate supports an inference about training or membership; it does not by itself establish the person's current command of a specific portfolio or the quality of past decisions.

Article 42 of the EU's Solvency II Directive (European Parliament and Council, 2009; consolidation of January 2025) establishes continuing requirements for relevant qualifications, knowledge and experience, as well as repute and integrity. Article 273 of the Solvency II delegated regulation (European Commission, 2015) elaborates assessment in relation to assigned duties and relevant professional capabilities.

A substantive competence assessment can examine how a candidate understands the insurer's sources of risk, recognizes limitations of data, reasons under uncertainty, communicates conclusions to nonspecialists and responds to disagreement. An interview for an actuarial control role, for example, can require the candidate to explain the limitations of a reserve estimate based on sparse claims development rather than merely calculate a standard result. A risk role may require reasoning about overlapping concentrations across assets, counterparties and products.

A useful scenario is one in which the answer requires identifying information that has not yet been supplied. A person who acknowledges the missing information, explains its consequences and requests appropriate independent corroboration demonstrates a form of judgment that routine technical questions alone may fail to reveal. The purpose is to evaluate reasoning relevant to the role, not to set a uniform examination for all insurance employees.

Experience should also be assessed for substance. An applicant may have participated in many reviews without having had responsibility for the outcome. Another may have had decisive authority in a smaller institution with relevant exposures. The assessment should distinguish years spent in a sector from the actual content of the work performed, the complexity of decisions taken and the candidate's ability to explain how those decisions were tested.

Integrity, reputation and financial soundness

Integrity is the reliability of conduct in the exercise of entrusted responsibility. Reputational evidence can provide indications about that reliability, but an assessment should distinguish supported facts, disputed claims, contextual circumstances and the relevance of an allegation to the particular function. A record of an event and the inference drawn from it belong in separate parts of an assessment.

IAIS guidance (2024) considers patterns of behavior, severity, elapsed time and subsequent conduct when examining adverse information. The UK's FCA fitness and propriety guidance (FCA, 2023) describes honesty and reputation, capability and financial soundness as principal dimensions of its regime.

Personal financial difficulties do not always have the same implications. A material failure to disclose a relevant financial interest may create an integrity concern, whereas a financial loss arising from a documented external event may have a different significance. Where legislation creates a disqualification, it must be applied; where the standard permits judgment, the reasons for the judgment should be explicit. The position held, the individual's control over the circumstances, recurrence, disclosure and the reliability of the evidence are all material considerations.

Probity assessment should also examine how people deal with unwelcome information. A control leader may be technically excellent yet systematically diminish findings that conflict with executive objectives. The issue relates to trustworthy exercise of the function. An honest mistake, disclosed promptly and corrected, supports a different inference from knowingly presenting false information or concealing a relevant conflict.

The assessment also requires appropriate handling of personal information. Canada's OSFI Guideline E-17 (2008) identifies internal assessment procedures, escalation and adverse-information notification while recognizing privacy and employment-law obligations. This supports an important distinction between collecting relevant evidence for prudential purposes and collecting unlimited data about an individual. Reliability improves when those making decisions understand what the evidence does and does not establish.

Integrity and independence in practice

Independence is an organizational and behavioral condition. A control officer may have an independent reporting line on paper while remuneration, delegated authority or career progression depends on people whose decisions are being challenged. A formal declaration of independence is therefore evidence about an arrangement; its practical significance depends on how that arrangement operates.

Consider a hypothetical actuarial officer asked to revise reserving assumptions immediately before a reporting deadline. The officer's competence concerns the statistical basis for the change, the adequacy of data and the uncertainty of the revised estimate. Integrity concerns whether the officer accurately represents the analysis, discloses unresolved disagreements and resists misleading presentation. Organizational independence concerns whether the officer can communicate this position directly to the governing body without retaliation. These are related conditions with separate evidentiary requirements.

A useful evaluation distinguishes an individual's behavior from the environment that encourages or suppresses appropriate conduct. Replacing a control officer will not repair a reporting structure that systematically prevents communication of material concerns. Equally, reforming a reporting structure will not cure demonstrated deliberate dishonesty in an incumbent. Appropriate intervention may require actions at both levels.

Proportionality and non-substitutable criteria

The granularity of assessment should correspond to the scale, nature and complexity of the institution and the significance of the person's role. A small captive insurer and an internationally active insurer with numerous subsidiaries may face different operational and technical demands. Neither difference in size nor limited availability of candidates establishes that material incompetence or impaired integrity should be accepted.

Some gaps can be addressed with reasonable training, bounded delegation or access to external expertise. Others concern legally mandatory qualifications or a lack of capability to perform immediate duties. The distinction is temporal as well as substantive: a development need that can be safely addressed before the person assumes a responsibility differs from a shortcoming that would leave an essential function unsupported from the first day.

An aggregate numerical score could obscure this distinction. High technical marks should not compensate for a mandatory disqualification, and impressive leadership experience should not erase a material conflict that prevents independent review. Any scoring used to organize evidence should retain threshold requirements, qualitative reasons for decisions and explicit treatment of unresolved issues.

Selection and appointment due diligence

Defining the role before examining the candidate

A defensible appointment begins with a description of the position that exists independently of the candidate. The description should identify substantive responsibility, decision authority, expected independence, access to information, required qualifications, internal and external reporting obligations and foreseeable changes in the insurer's risk profile. A criterion invented after identifying a preferred candidate may conceal selection bias.

The definition should also describe the organizational interfaces of the role. A chief risk officer who reports regularly to an independent risk committee has a different operating environment from an officer whose communications must pass through the executives who own the risks under review. The candidate's suitability can be judged only in relation to that environment.

Role description and selection criteria should be dated. This makes it possible to distinguish subsequent changes in requirements from deficiencies in the original judgment. It also gives the insurer a baseline for evaluating whether succession arrangements preserve the capabilities needed by the function.

Sources and quality of evidence

An assessment file should bring together several types of evidence. Credentials can be confirmed with issuing bodies where relevant and lawful. Employment history can establish experience, supported by appropriately obtained references. Interviews and role-relevant scenarios can address current capability. Conflict disclosures and applicable regulatory or professional records provide evidence about integrity and independence. The historical record of assessment decisions provides context for later changes.

Evidence quality depends on its origin, independence, specificity and date. An unverified self-declaration has different evidentiary weight from an authentic official document. A general character reference may contribute little to evaluating whether a person can challenge complex reserving assumptions. A reference from someone whose interests are aligned with the candidate may be useful but requires appropriate interpretation.

A structured record can show what has been verified, when the verification occurred, what information remains outstanding and how uncertainty was addressed. This is particularly important for international appointments where credentials, prior roles and professional disciplinary systems may be organized differently. Translation quality, legal restrictions on data exchange and differences in institutional terminology can affect comparability.

Article 43 of Solvency II provides an example of formal cross-border recognition of certain good-repute and bankruptcy evidence among EU Member States. The rule concerns specified documents and circumstances rather than universal equivalence of supervisory assessments. The ability to authenticate evidence across borders remains a separate issue from the substantive assessment of capability.

Independent decision and documented rationale

The body responsible for selection should distinguish the commercial case for recruiting a person from the prudential judgment about entrusting authority. Individuals with an interest in the appointment may possess useful role knowledge, but conflicts should be identified and managed. Human resources can coordinate collection of records; specialist functions can evaluate technical capability; an independent body can assess the reasons for the decision and challenge unresolved evidence.

A coherent decision record states the role, applicable criteria, supporting and adverse evidence, reasons for treating any unresolved item as immaterial or material, and any approved appointment conditions. If training or supervision is considered sufficient to address a gap, the record should specify the relevant period, person responsible for monitoring progress, assessment method and consequences of failure.

Administrative approval by a supervisor and an internal hiring decision are distinct actions. The insurer may determine that the person is professionally suitable and still need to obtain formal approval before the individual performs particular responsibilities. Conversely, prior regulatory approval for a different role does not resolve whether the person can perform a new role within a changed risk environment.

The PRA Senior Managers Regime (PRA, n.d.) illustrates this allocation: designated senior management functions require prior approval, and firms undertake assessment for employees within the relevant certification regime. Qualification transferability and previous experience can inform the review without turning approval into a portable credential valid for every role.

Interim appointments and incomplete evidence

A sudden departure creates a tension between maintaining essential controls and ensuring a proper appointment. A vacancy can delay risk review and increase the burden on remaining personnel. An inappropriate temporary appointment can expose the insurer to an even greater risk through unsupported authority.

APRA's 2018 interim appointment rule permits certain interim appointments for up to 90 days, longer with written agreement from APRA, subject to preliminary reasonable assessment and completion of full assessment before permanent appointment. This is a jurisdiction-specific statutory-framework provision, not a general international deadline.

A prudent institution can anticipate this problem through succession planning. Potential successors should be identified in relation to specific responsibilities; cross-training should preserve access to necessary expertise; interim delegations should define the limits of authority. When a key role becomes vacant, essential decisions can be routed to suitably authorized persons and heightened oversight applied while a replacement is assessed.

The quality of an interim arrangement can be judged by whether it preserves the function's essential outputs and independent reporting, not solely by the speed with which a nominal vacancy is filled.

Collective suitability and changing risk profiles

Individual and collective competence

A board combines the judgment of individuals into a governing process. Its overall competence depends on the availability and integration of relevant knowledge across its membership. Collective competence therefore includes both coverage of relevant domains and the capacity to apply that knowledge in shared decisions.

Article 273(3) of the delegated Solvency II regulation (2015) connects board assessment to the distribution of duties and diversity of qualifications and experience. The IAIS addresses combined and individual board competence in its requirements for internationally active insurance groups. These provisions support the differentiation of individual suitability and collective coverage.

An illustrative board may include investment expertise, insurance underwriting experience, actuarial or financial knowledge, technology expertise and regulatory understanding. The distribution must correspond to the institution's business, rather than be treated as a universal numerical quota. Directors need enough common understanding to evaluate information outside their specialties and to recognize when additional inquiry is necessary.

A collective distribution of expertise does not justify assigning a person responsibility for a technical function that the person cannot perform. Nor does it cure individual integrity or legal eligibility concerns. Collective suitability is an additional governance dimension. It responds to institutional complexity by enabling multiple informed perspectives on the same decision.

Capability concentration and redundancy

A board may possess all the relevant domains of expertise through a single individual. That creates exposure to absence, departure or a conflict involving that person. A competency inventory should distinguish between broad coverage and dependence on a single expert. It should also consider whether the expertise is active or dormant: possessing a qualification may be less useful if the member cannot participate effectively in deliberations.

For example, if only one director understands long-duration liabilities, the departure of that director can remove the board's capacity to challenge a change in discount-rate assumptions. Hiring a replacement with the same general professional title may fail to restore the required capability if that person has experience only with short-term business.

A skills matrix can make concentrations visible. Its entries should describe observable role-relevant evidence rather than simply list credentials. Board and committee responsibilities, expected participation, succession arrangements and training records provide additional information. The matrix is a descriptive tool for organizing existing assessments, not a newly proposed universal measurement model.

Changes in the risk profile

Suitability is affected by changes on either side of the person-role relationship. The person may acquire experience, lose a professional authorization or become subject to a material conflict. The insurer may enter a new line, acquire a subsidiary, adopt a new underwriting technology or become exposed to different concentrations.

Consider a property insurer that introduces a large cyber insurance portfolio. The move changes the questions faced by underwriting, reserving, risk management and governance. A previously competent board may lack sufficient understanding of correlated losses, coverage accumulation, provider concentration or limitations of incident data. It may need new expertise and independent challenge arrangements before or alongside the strategic expansion.

The same reasoning applies to investment transformation. Replacing straightforward portfolios with complex private-credit assets may alter liquidity, valuation and counterparty concerns. If the investment committee cannot assess these mechanisms, the capabilities needed from its members have changed even if the membership itself remains unchanged.

A risk-sensitive reassessment can originate from planned strategic changes, material incidents, findings in audits, regulatory developments, new responsibilities or significant changes in a person's circumstances. Calendar reassessment establishes routine accountability. Under Australia's CPS 520 assessment requirements (APRA, 2018), an initial assessment is ordinarily followed by annual assessment, with further inquiries when new information may materially affect suitability. Event-driven assessment responds to emerging information between scheduled reviews.

Evidence of operational capability

An assessment should consider whether the person actually exercises the role with sufficient resources and support. Examples of relevant evidence include documented challenges to assumptions, material issues escalated, responses to adverse findings, continuing professional development and the handling of conflicts. The significance of any single item depends on its context.

An absence of recorded objections is ambiguous. It may indicate a well-functioning business or a culture in which objections are discouraged. Similarly, a large number of escalations may demonstrate alertness or an underlying deterioration in operations. Counts should therefore be interpreted with information about exposure, seriousness, reporting incentives and subsequent remediation.

Training should address identified changes and deficiencies, rather than be measured solely by attendance. A director who can articulate the implications of a new product structure after training provides stronger evidence of practical learning than a certificate of completion alone. Development is most useful when it is linked to observed responsibilities and a subsequent assessment of capability.

Group-wide supervision and outsourced functions

Insurance groups can centralize specialist functions to improve access to expertise and consistency. Centralization can also create difficulties when local responsibilities, reporting obligations and access to group specialists are unclear. Group-level capability should not be treated as proof of local suitability.

A person leading a shared function may serve multiple legal entities with differing business profiles and local obligations. A suitability assessment should examine whether the person has sufficient capacity, local knowledge and effective reporting arrangements for those responsibilities. Where a local individual oversees an outsourced function, the ability to assess the provider and the ability to perform every underlying technical task are distinguishable.

The supervisory question is whether responsibility can be traced to an appropriately suited person who has access to evidence and authority to escalate concerns. Outsourcing may alter the way evidence is obtained; it should not make the person responsible for evaluating the evidence impossible to identify.

Supervisory notification, intervention and removal

Notifications and the distinction between processes

A material adverse change can become relevant before an insurer reaches a final internal conclusion. Notification rules therefore serve a different purpose from the ultimate decision about fitness and propriety. A notification informs the supervisor within the applicable framework; it need not amount to a determination that the person is unsuitable.

Under Article 42 of Solvency II (2009), undertakings notify the supervisor of changes in relevant officeholders and notify replacement resulting from loss of suitability. IAIS ICP 5 also addresses material adverse circumstances and supervisory corrective action. Domestic rules determine the precise trigger, recipient, timing, contents and legal consequences of notifications.

An assessment file can preserve a chronology of when evidence became known, who received it, what initial action was taken and when the matter was reassessed. A notification log is particularly useful for examining delays between the emergence of a concern and action. Legal deadlines should be recorded against the actual applicable rule rather than inferred from another country's practice.

The distinction between notification and conclusion helps avoid two errors: treating the submission of an allegation as a definitive finding and waiting until the outcome is beyond doubt when a material preliminary concern already requires notification.

Corrective intervention and removal

Responses should correspond to the type and materiality of the deficiency. A bounded, remediable gap in technical knowledge may justify additional training and supervised development if the applicable rules permit the appointment or continuing role. A conflict that prevents independent assessment may require a changed allocation of responsibility. A finding of serious dishonesty or inability to meet an indispensable legal criterion may require removal or refusal of appointment.

IAIS guidance under ICP 5.5 discusses responses extending from education and external assistance to restrictions on appointment. APRA's CPS 520 addresses removal or nonappointment of persons who fail the applicable criteria and contains provisions supporting disclosure of relevant information to the regulator.

The insurer's duty to act on unsuitable persons and the supervisor's authority to intervene are complementary. The insurer is typically in a position to observe information quickly and to maintain essential functions. The supervisory authority may compare evidence across the market, assess whether the firm has responded adequately and exercise powers available under local law.

A removal decision should specify which responsibilities end, how the function will operate during the transition and how any previously issued material determinations will be examined. If the concern relates to integrity of prior reports, the insurer may need to determine whether underlying business or financial decisions relied on those reports. If the problem concerns lack of expertise, a review may focus on decisions outside the individual's demonstrated competence. The remedy should address the consequences of the deficiency as well as future authority.

Fairness, uncertainty and confidentiality

Procedural quality affects the reliability of the assessment itself. A person should be evaluated against the applicable criteria and the actual evidentiary record, with appropriate opportunity to correct inaccurate information or explain disputed circumstances when the legal framework permits. The procedure should preserve distinctions among established facts, unresolved allegations, professional judgment and binding disqualifications.

Confidentiality, employment law, data protection and regulatory disclosure obligations can affect what evidence may be collected, transmitted or retained. These matters require local analysis. Where an immediate threat to the integrity of a function exists, temporary restrictions may be appropriate within the institution's lawful authority while relevant facts are examined. Such restrictions are distinct from a final adverse finding.

Written reasons also facilitate internal review and supervisory scrutiny. An opaque conclusion may prevent later investigators from determining whether a prior assessment was based on appropriate evidence. A concise, reasoned record creates accountability for decision-makers and allows newly available information to be evaluated against the original rationale.

Whistleblowing and escalation

Some relevant evidence is available initially only to people inside an institution. An employee may observe a control officer suppressing material results, a director concealing a conflict or an executive discouraging escalation. A credible assessment process needs a route for this information to reach an independent decision-maker.

The Australian standard includes whistleblowing provisions for suitability concerns. The practical challenge is to distinguish a channel's formal availability from the likelihood that staff can use it without retaliation. A process that discourages good-faith reporting through managerial pressure may have apparently clean records while material problems remain hidden.

The assessment of an adverse report should begin with the issue raised, its source and potential corroboration. Safeguards for good-faith reporting and a fair treatment of the person assessed serve compatible purposes: both support accuracy of the facts on which the decision depends.

Continuity of the insurance function

A replacement is operationally effective only if the underlying responsibilities continue to be exercised. Insurance obligations do not stop because a director, actuary or risk officer is removed. Critical reporting, oversight of claims, valuation and the monitoring of exposures may need to proceed throughout a transition.

Transition plans can identify the information and access required by successors, unresolved issues, upcoming deadlines and the allocation of interim authority. An insurer may also examine whether reporting to its governing body and supervisory authority needs adjustment during the vacancy. This preserves the continuity of governance while the new appointment is assessed.

Comparative effectiveness and evidence gaps

Comparative regulatory arrangements

The comparison reveals common objectives pursued through different distributions of authority, information and timing. The IAIS establishes the benchmark; national arrangements translate that benchmark into different types of legal and administrative processes.

Framework Principal mechanism examined Population or focus Distinguishing feature
IAIS (2024) International supervisory benchmark Board, senior management, key control personnel, significant owners Continuing suitability and corrective action
EU Solvency II Directive and delegated regulation Persons effectively running undertakings or holding other key functions Continuing legal duty, notification and role-sensitive criteria
United Kingdom SM&CR supervisory arrangements Designated senior managers and relevant certification personnel Allocation of approval and firm certification responsibilities
Australia CPS 520 prudential standard Responsible persons within defined institutions and groups Documented process, reassessment and additional professional criteria
Canada OSFI E-17 guidance Responsible persons within federally regulated entities as defined by the guideline Suitability and integrity background-check processes
California Corporate governance annual disclosure Insurer or insurance group governance practices Supervisory visibility of the firm's suitability standards and changes

These are comparisons of mechanisms actually examined, not a ranking of entire legal systems. The mechanisms may coexist with additional sectoral requirements not analyzed here. A California disclosure arrangement, for example, can demonstrate how the supervisor obtains information about internal suitability procedures without establishing that the jurisdiction has no separate appointment or licensing powers.

The California governance disclosure guidance (California Department of Insurance, n.d.) requests descriptions of the insurer's standards for officers and key control personnel and changes to suitability. Its significance in this analysis is the supervisory visibility of how firms govern these judgments. It cannot be treated as a comprehensive description of all U.S. state laws.

Regulatory time and reform

Legal comparison requires distinguishing an instrument's adoption, publication and application. The EU Solvency II amending directive (2025) sets January 29, 2027 as the transposition deadline and January 30, 2027 as the general application date for the prescribed measures. Those dates follow this study's cutoff. Requirements from the forthcoming consolidated text are therefore not presented as already applicable throughout the EU in November 2026.

In the UK, the PRA's Phase 1 policy statement (2026a) documents the 2026 reform sequence, including the correction of omitted reference-related text in the insurance supervisory statement. The subsequent Phase 2 consultation (2026b) proposes additional changes. Consultation material is evidence of intended reform, not evidence that the proposed rules have entered into force.

This temporal separation matters for comparative studies of appointments. A regulatory provision may be adopted in one period and enforced in another, with transitional arrangements affecting the population subject to the change. An evaluation that uses the publication date as the intervention date could misclassify observations.

What insurer-governance studies show

Insurance-specific empirical studies provide evidence about the relevance of board experience and governance arrangements. Adams and Jiang (2020), in their study of board financial expertise, report favorable associations for financial experts collectively and for qualified accountants and actuaries across the six selected outcomes in the UK non-life industry. Their abstract also distinguishes underwriting expertise from earnings-based outcomes. These observations support the importance of differentiating professional capabilities by the outcomes under examination.

Eling and Marek (2012), in their UK and German risk study, examine stock-price variation using a panel of 35 insurers from 1997 through 2010. The authors report associations involving firm characteristics and economic conditions. The measure of market risk and the sample composition restrict the conclusions that can be transferred to other insurance institutions.

Goyal and Gulati (2023) examine board and audit governance in a meta-analysis of 32 studies published from 2003 to 2021. The abstract reports favorable associations for outside directors and audit committee presence, while identifying contextual differences for other governance attributes. This reinforces the need to examine operational independence and local institutional context rather than equating a common formal governance arrangement with identical outcomes.

For these three publications, the evidence used in this study is limited to the displayed abstracts and bibliographic records. Detailed coefficient estimates, identification tests and robustness findings cannot be independently verified from that access and are not asserted here. These articles address governance attributes and outcomes rather than the causal effect of a particular fit and proper approval process.

The full-text study of co-opted boards by Adams and Kastrinaki (2024) examines UK property and casualty insurers and differentiates board appointments associated with CEO succession from outside directorial expertise. Its results associate insider co-option with lower profitability and stronger solvency, while experienced outsiders are associated with profitability. The authors employ dynamic panel estimation and acknowledge sample limitations. The coexistence of different profitability and solvency associations matters for supervisory assessment: board composition cannot be evaluated through a single performance indicator. These findings concern board appointments and financial outcomes; they do not identify the causal effect of a statutory fit and proper procedure or establish individual integrity.

A historical supervisory assessment

A different kind of evidence is provided by the IMF's 2024 Japan insurance assessment. The report's ICP 5 assessment identifies gaps in the coverage of senior management and some control function personnel at the time of assessment, as well as supervisory resource constraints affecting continuing oversight. This is a dated institutional observation, not a determination about the current legal status of Japan.

Its comparative significance is methodological. The existence of a formal suitability rule, the completeness of the covered population and the supervisor's ability to evaluate compliance are distinct characteristics. A country can have mechanisms for the assessment of specified persons while some relevant populations remain outside explicit criteria or supervision lacks the resources for broad continuing assessment.

The case illustrates how observations from institutional assessments can be used to identify dimensions for further research. They cannot establish the current position without examination of subsequent changes.

Why causal effectiveness is difficult to establish

The effect of fit and proper assessment cannot be inferred simply from subsequent insurer solvency. A well-capitalized insurer can experience a governance failure; an insurer with sound governance can suffer unusually severe external losses. Sound performance may reflect an underwriting cycle, investment returns or management practices unrelated to the particular suitability decision.

Candidate selection is endogenous. Large insurers may attract more qualified individuals and possess stronger internal resources. Troubled insurers may change leadership and undergo more intensive supervisory review. Both mechanisms can create correlations between assessment intensity and outcomes without revealing the causal contribution of the assessment.

Regulatory reforms often change multiple parts of a governance system simultaneously. If approval requirements, capital standards and supervisory powers change together, an observed difference in loss outcomes cannot be attributed to individual suitability rules without an identification strategy that separates these changes.

Data availability creates a further limitation. Individual assessment files are generally sensitive, and publicly observable approval or removal decisions may represent a selected subset of the underlying population. Confidential supervisory information may be necessary to identify rejected appointments, unresolved adverse information or cases remediated without public intervention.

A credible empirical design would need to specify the exposure of interest, the eligible population, the timing of the intervention, plausible comparison groups and relevant outcome measures. It would also require examination of selection, reporting incentives and changes in other regulatory requirements. No such dataset is constructed here; the scientific contribution is comparative and interpretive.

Process indicators and their interpretation

Indicators can support evaluation when they are connected to the underlying decision processes. Relevant measures might include coverage of the regulated population, completion of role-specific assessments, elapsed time between material concerns and their escalation, the quality of evidence, completion of development actions and the duration of unfilled essential functions.

An example illustrates the role of denominators. Suppose an insurer completes 49 of 50 scheduled assessments, yielding 98 percent calendar completion. The unassessed position is the only officer responsible for challenging reserves on a major long-tail portfolio. The completion percentage is arithmetically accurate but conceals an exposure of particular significance. A coverage indicator should be interpreted alongside the identity and responsibilities of unassessed persons.

Suppose a separate insurer records ten substantive concerns in one year and two in another. Without information about changes in staff, risk exposures and the willingness of employees to report concerns, it is impossible to conclude that suitability improved. A decline in recorded concerns could reflect effective remediation or diminished reporting.

A supervisor's approval speed is similarly informative about administrative timeliness, not about the accuracy of decisions. PRA PS12/26 reports attainment of a 45-day processing target for 85 percent of applications during December 2025 through February 2026. This reported metric concerns the broader application-processing process; it is not an insurance-only measure or a validation of the quality of approvals.

Original analytical synthesis

The comparative evidence supports the interpretation of suitability as a continuing institutional judgment composed of distinguishable elements. At the level of the individual, the relevant evidence concerns competence, integrity and capacity to fulfill the function. At the level of the governing body, the question concerns the collective availability and effective use of expertise. At the level of the firm, the question concerns the selection, assessment and escalation arrangements. At the level of supervision, the question concerns access to reliable information and the ability to require appropriate correction.

These elements are interdependent. An honest, competent individual may be unable to discharge a function if reporting arrangements deprive the individual of relevant information. A strong organizational structure may still fail if the person controlling critical information is unsuitable. Effective supervision depends in part on the quality and timeliness of the firm's records, while credible supervisory scrutiny changes the incentives for the firm to maintain those records.

The strongest implication is that assurance should be connected to the significance of the underlying risk rather than administrative completeness alone. Credentials, declarations and appointments have to be interpretable in the context of the role. Subsequent decisions, escalation and organizational changes supply additional information about the continued relevance of the original judgment.

A second implication concerns the treatment of professional diversity. Different expertise contributes to the quality of governance through different mechanisms. Technical knowledge of actuarial uncertainty, accounting knowledge of reporting, experience with underwriting and understanding of policyholder obligations each contribute distinct perspectives. Assessment should identify how those perspectives are integrated in actual deliberation and whether the board remains capable of functioning when an expert leaves.

A third implication concerns intervention. A system of continuing assessment is credible when material deficiencies lead to appropriate, traceable action. The purpose of the action is to restore reliable performance of the function and protect the insurer's obligations. A decision to remove a person, for example, is incomplete as an institutional response if the vacancy causes essential control responsibilities to be neglected.

These are analytical conclusions derived from the comparison, not a claim to have discovered a new regulatory doctrine or to have established an empirically validated model. Their practical scientific value lies in clarifying what should be examined in studies of governance and where uncertainty remains.

Conclusion

Fit and proper assessment provides a means of examining the suitability of people occupying positions of material authority in insurance. Its substantive criteria concern the capability to carry out assigned responsibilities and integrity in their exercise. Its procedural dimensions include initial assessment, documentation, continuing observation, notification and corrective action.

The international comparison identifies common prudential objectives alongside meaningful differences in scope, decision ownership and supervisory mechanism. The IAIS provides a common reference; the EU framework establishes continuing statutory duties; the UK distinguishes designated approval and certification processes; Australia specifies responsible-person procedures; Canadian and California examples highlight selected evidentiary and disclosure mechanisms.

The relationship between individual and collective suitability is central. The diversity of expertise within a board can improve its capacity to evaluate strategic decisions. Individual holders nevertheless remain responsible for the suitability required by their own roles. Changes in business, personnel and exposure can require a new judgment even when the original appointment was satisfactory.

The credibility of continuing assessment depends on an insurer's ability to detect relevant evidence, preserve records, distinguish adverse allegations from established facts, act on deficiencies and maintain essential governance functions during transition. This connects the suitability decision to the insurer's continuing obligations to policyholders.

The reviewed empirical literature demonstrates the relevance of governance attributes and financial expertise to insurer outcomes, while leaving the causal effect of alternative fit and proper regimes unresolved. Further research requires longitudinal assessment data, clearly defined intervention dates, appropriate comparison populations and differentiation between process quality and financial outcomes.

The principal conclusion is that the scientific study of suitability must account for the individual, the role, the governing body, the insurer's institutional processes and the supervisor's capacity to observe and intervene. These connected objects explain why appointment records are necessary, why continuing reassessment matters and why procedural completeness alone cannot demonstrate that an essential insurance responsibility is being exercised competently and with integrity.

References

  • International Association of Insurance Supervisors (IAIS). (2024). Insurance Core Principles and Common Framework for the Supervision of Internationally Active Insurance Groups, ICP 5: Suitability of persons. Revision adopted December 5, 2024. Official source.

  • European Parliament and Council. (2009). Directive 2009/138/EC of November 25, 2009 on the taking-up and pursuit of the business of Insurance and Reinsurance (Solvency II). OJ L 335, December 17, 2009, 1-155. Consolidated January 17, 2025. Consolidated directive.

  • European Commission. (2015). Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 of October 10, 2014 supplementing Directive 2009/138/EC. OJ L 12, January 17, 2015, 1-797. Official delegated regulation.

  • European Parliament and Council. (2025). Directive (EU) 2025/2 of November 27, 2024 amending Directive 2009/138/EC and related directives. OJ L, 2025/2, January 8, 2025. Amending directive.

  • Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA). (2018). Prudential Standard CPS 520 Fit and Proper. Banking, Insurance, Life Insurance and Health Insurance (prudential standard) determination No. 2 of 2018. Commences July 1, 2019. Official source.

  • Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA). (n.d.). Senior Managers Regime. Bank of England. Official source.

  • Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). (2023). Fitness and Propriety (F&P). March 30, 2023. Official source.

  • Prudential Regulation Authority. (2026a). PS12/26: Review of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) — Phase 1. April 2026. Bank of England. Official source.

  • Prudential Regulation Authority. (2026b). CP14/26: Review of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) — Phase 2. October 2026. Bank of England. Official source.

  • Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI). (2008). Background Checks on Directors and Senior Management of Federally Regulated Entities. Guideline E-17. Canada. Official source.

  • California Department of Insurance. (n.d.). Corporate Governance Annual Disclosure (CGAD). Official source.

  • Adams, M., & Jiang, W. (2020). Do financial experts on the board matter? An empirical test from the United Kingdom's non-life insurance industry. Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance, 35(1), 168-195. DOI: 10.1177/0148558X17705201. Online first 2017. Institutional research record.

  • Eling, M., & Marek, S. D. (2012). Internal and external drivers for risk taking in UK and German insurance markets. International Journal of Banking, Accounting and Finance, 4(1), 48-76. DOI: 10.1504/IJBAAF.2012.045513. Publisher research record.

  • Goyal, B., & Gulati, R. (2023). Do board and audit governance matters for insurer performance? A meta-analytical review. DECISION, 50(3), 285-319. DOI: 10.1007/s40622-023-00351-2. Bibliographic research record.

  • International Monetary Fund. (2024). Japan: Financial Sector Assessment Program—Detailed Assessment of Observance on Insurance Core Principles. IMF Country Report No. 24/110. DOI: 10.5089/9798400275166.002. IMF country report.

  • Adams, M., & Kastrinaki, Z. (2024). Do Co-opted Boards Affect the Financial Performance of Insurance Firms? Journal of Financial Services Research, 66, 329–357. DOI: 10.1007/s10693-023-00418-2. Journal article.