Insurance by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Insurance and Risk Science

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Cyber Insurance War Attribution and State Backed Attack Exclusions

Abstract. Cyber insurance war exclusions determine the allocation of losses arising from conflict-related and state-linked digital operations. Their application depends on the policy's definitions of war, state involvement, causation, affected infrastructure, territorial reach, and the evidence needed to establish these facts. This study compares the traditional property-policy war exclusion considered in Merck with the Lloyd’s state-backed cyber-attack exclusion requirements and a concrete commercial endorsement. It separates technical identification, public governmental attribution, international legal responsibility, and contractual coverage adjudication. The NotPetya and KA-SAT incidents illustrate the difference between propagation, operational disruption, responsibility, and indemnity. Reported litigation outcomes and U.S. cyber premium statistics are interpreted within their own evidentiary populations. Worked hypothetical calculations demonstrate how exclusion breadth, disputed attribution, dependency concentration, and reinsurance mismatch affect expected loss, liquidity, and risk retention. The analysis finds that attribution alone cannot establish an exclusion, that the geographical extent of insured effects is a separate contractual decision, and that correlated economic loss persists even when excluded from an insurance portfolio. The evidence supports comparative documentary findings rather than a representative estimate of war-related claims or a new theory.

Keywords: Cyber insurance; cyber war; state-backed cyber operations; attribution; insurance exclusion; insurance contract law; NotPetya; KA-SAT; Lloyd’s; systemic cyber risk; claims adjustment; accumulation; reinsurance; uncertainty; insurance protection gap.

Introduction

Cyber insurance allocates financial consequences among policyholders, insurers, reinsurers, and other institutions. War exclusions are consequential because they can alter that allocation simultaneously across many insureds precisely when a digital disruption is most expensive. A wording designed to confine aggregate liabilities can also create an unexpected gap for a firm geographically remote from conflict whose operating systems depend on a service disrupted elsewhere. The coverage question is therefore a joint inquiry into the characteristics of an operation and into the rules of a particular contract.

Three questions organize this dossier. First, what elements distinguish inherited war language from express state-backed cyber exclusions? Second, how does evidence about a cyber operation enter a legal decision about state involvement and other contractual predicates? Third, how do different policy choices affect losses at firm and portfolio levels, and what can available observations establish about coverage outcomes?

The method is comparative documentary analysis, with legal interpretation limited to the relevant jurisdiction and the exact text considered. The corpus is purposively selected for relevance: a published New Jersey appellate decision, dated Lloyd’s requirements, market association explanations, an actual specimen endorsement, official attribution statements, an operator incident account, recent aggregate market statistics, and selected scholarship. The unit of legal analysis is the clause in its policy and applicable law; the unit of incident analysis is an operation and the identifiable affected system; the unit of financial analysis is a claim or a defined portfolio. The study does not treat these as interchangeable observations. Source records identify the inspected portions, including abstract-only access. The quantitative exercises use deliberately constructed assumptions. No proprietary claims records, classified intelligence, paid litigation files, signed private policies, or actual reinsurance slips were available.

The institutional comparison covers the London insurance market, New Jersey property insurance litigation, the German market as a subject of peer-reviewed research, and international governmental attribution. It is not a comprehensive survey of all national insurance laws. Public incident reports may be valuable and incomplete; statements made by a government identify its official judgment rather than automatically establishing binding facts in private litigation. The source cutoff is a research date, not a publication date.

Conceptual and Historical Foundations

The insured subject and the event

The economic object of a cyber policy is a contingent financial obligation. A malicious operation produces a technology event; a technology event can impair a business process; impairment can create measurable losses; a subset may satisfy a coverage grant; another subset may be excluded. A claim is the insured's demand under a policy, and an indemnity is the eventual payment or other contractual performance. The distinction matters for all insurance research, especially at the extreme tail. A count of damaged computers cannot be converted directly into a count of paid claims.

Cyber war is used in several senses. It can describe a digital dimension of armed conflict, a political characterization of hostile behavior, or an expression contained in a policy. State backing concerns a relationship between an operation and state institutions. War and state backing intersect, but an operation can serve state objectives without occurring during an armed conflict; an incident during a war can also have independent criminal causes. A privately motivated extortion group may exploit the disorder of a conflict without acting for a state. A criminal organization may receive state direction for one campaign while conducting financially motivated activities independently at other times. The unit of attribution is consequently the relevant conduct, not a permanent label applied to every activity of a group.

War language historically addresses the uncertain severity and accumulation of conflict losses. Digital insurance brings the same financial problem into an infrastructure in which actors, customers, hardware, software and operating effects are dispersed. A political boundary and the boundary of a technology service may diverge sharply. A domestic company using foreign cloud infrastructure may suffer local business interruption while the affected system is outside its home state. Conversely, a foreign insured may lose income even when its hardware remains intact. Geographic exclusion language must establish the relevant object of location: the computer system, dependent service, insured premises, impaired state, or the loss itself.

The June 2017 NotPetya operation became an important illustration of legacy language applied to digital damage. The UK government's 2018 NotPetya attribution statement assigned responsibility to the Russian military and described effects beyond Ukraine. The attribution was announced months after the operation. The difference between occurrence and public attribution creates a timing issue for insureds and claims handlers even when a later government assessment is highly confident.

The transition from inherited to express language

In the United States, the published Merck appellate ruling addressed property policies whose scope included certain damage to computer systems or data. The dispute centered on inherited hostile/warlike language rather than a modern bespoke exclusion addressing state-backed cyber operations. It demonstrates that a policy may afford affirmative computer-related coverage while an insurer invokes a traditional exclusion. Silent cyber, in contrast, refers to uncertainty about cyber exposure in contracts where cyber is not expressly addressed in a particular way. The two issues can coexist across a portfolio, but they describe different contractual problems.

Lloyd’s 2022 Market Bulletin Y5381 responded specifically to potential accumulations from state-backed operations and set minimum requirements for a defined category of standalone cyber insurance. The central institutional shift was from relying on inherited war wording to expressing when state operations fall outside the intended risk transfer. This change improves specification only to the extent that the newly used terms can be interpreted and evidenced; it does not remove uncertainty about the identity or conduct of attackers.

Different institutions, different decisions

A government assesses security incidents in national and international contexts. A forensic investigator develops an incident reconstruction. A court or agreed adjudicator applies governing law and policy language to a contested claim. A market supervisor evaluates exposure management and institutional soundness. A reinsurer evaluates ceded liabilities against treaty terms. These decisions may refer to overlapping information but have different purposes, governing instruments and standards.

For example, a public assessment may be framed at campaign level while a claim requires proof that a particular loss arose from a component of that campaign. A national-security statement may be useful proof of actor involvement, but the causal relation between malicious activity and the insured's claimed loss requires distinct evidence. The amount of recovery cost caused by a covered event may also require independent verification. The financial effect of a government attribution thus depends on how the private contract connects that information to its operative terms.

Primary Documents and Scope of War Language

The Merck decision and its limits

The New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division, in Merck v. ACE (2023), considered consolidated appeals from partial summary judgment in favor of Merck and its captive. The all-risk property policies at issue contained an exclusion for hostile or warlike action. The appellate court concluded that the exclusion, read in context, required military action of the kind contemplated by the clause and that insurers had not demonstrated its applicability to the circumstances of the NotPetya loss. This is a holding about particular language and facts under New Jersey insurance law. It does not establish that every attack using digital means necessarily lies beyond every war exclusion.

The insurer argument treated the hostile aspect of the phrase as sufficiently broad to reach ill-intentioned governmental conduct. The court rejected that construction after considering the surrounding terms and prior interpretations. The difference is economically material. If any government-linked adverse action were enough, state involvement could function as the operative exclusion even where a contract otherwise appeared to insure cyber damage. A historically narrower interpretation makes the substance and context of hostile action independently relevant.

The HTML reproduction of the opinion preserves the account of the insurers' consultant and the footnote identifying attribution as contested. The trial court did not need to resolve attribution to decide the exclusion question. Thus the opinion cannot properly be read as a judicial finding of the attacker's identity. This distinction is especially useful because a government statement and an insurer's investigation can both be relevant evidence without resolving an independent interpretive issue. The judicial result is intelligible even if one provisionally assumes the attribution advanced by the insurers.

Ebert's January 2024 settlement report describes settlement ahead of review by the New Jersey Supreme Court and confidential terms. The appellate decision should not be inflated into a state supreme court merits ruling. Alleged loss and settlement consideration are also distinct quantities. No settlement amount is used in this research as a verified indemnity. Martin's Mondelez settlement report of October 2022 identifies a second resolved dispute arising from NotPetya, also without a public merits decision established in the materials examined. The two proceedings furnish evidence of interpretive friction, not a population of judicial outcomes from which to calculate the success rate of war defenses.

A comparative legal researcher should preserve procedural posture. Partial summary judgment on an exclusion does not alone determine the amount payable across all policy layers. Settlement can reflect costs of further litigation, uncertainty, liquidity, contractual obligations, or commercial decisions. The reason for settlement cannot reliably be reconstructed from its occurrence.

Lloyd’s requirements in their original scope

Y5381 applies to standalone cyber-attack policies within Lloyd’s specified risk codes CY and CZ, subject to agreed exceptions. Its dated implementation was tied to inception or renewal beginning March 31, 2023. The bulletin required coverage language addressing war, significant impairment of a state's functioning or security capabilities caused by state-backed operations, territorial consequences involving systems outside an affected state, an attribution basis, and defined terminology. It anticipated coordination with reinsurance arrangements. These are underwriting requirements of a particular market rather than a universal statute or an automatic amendment of every insurance contract in the world.

The next relevant institutional source is Market Bulletin Y5433 of May 14, 2024. It refined oversight using a taxonomy of clause types and separate transition schedules for primary cyber insurance and treaty reinsurance. The bulletin phased out noncompliant Type 7 insurance wording for relevant new and renewal business incepting July 1, 2024 and applied the corresponding treaty restriction from January 1, 2025. Type 4 use also ceased for relevant inception dates from January 1, 2025; conventional-war cyber exposure could instead be offered through a distinct affirmative coverage grant within the specified framework. Historically permitted runoff must be distinguished from new underwriting. These dates describe the reviewed bulletin; they do not certify every policy or subsequent market change.

The Lloyd’s Market Association's January 2023 replacement clause bulletin described A versions with attribution provisions and B versions lacking them. The latter required additional agreement with Lloyd’s to satisfy the relevant requirement. The distinction shows that an attribution mechanism can form part of the wording architecture independently of the substantive breadth of the exclusion.

The same institution's later clause corrections bulletin removed unintended writeback language from two alternatives. This is evidence of a material version-control problem: a short phrase can change the population of covered losses. A claims file should reproduce the issued wording and endorsement date rather than identify a loss merely by a model family name. A model's revision is not proof that parties incorporated that revision into their contract.

Comparative structure of exclusions

The LMA clause classification table distinguishes alternatives by the scope of war and non-war state-backed operations, severe national impairment, the treatment of effects outside the impaired state, and alternative indicators of severity. The table below summarizes those descriptions as research abstractions. It is not substitute wording.

Type Main scope in the classification Material issue for claims
1 Broad exclusion of state-linked operations in war and outside war Establish state relationship and causal connection
2 War operations and severe non-war state impairment Test conflict nexus or impairment and affected loss
3 Type 2 approach with territorial relief for certain non-war impacts outside impaired state Determine the legally relevant location and qualifying effect
4 Type 3-style approach with additional territorial relief for certain war operations Historical transition and affirmative coverage requirements
5 Type 2 or 3-style approach using alternative severity indicators Check the exact combined provisions and thresholds

The labels summarize categories, not enforceable promises on their own. An endorsement may be classified at one time, subsequently revised, or combined with terms elsewhere in the policy. The clauses must be read as a whole. The phrase war risk can therefore describe a narrower or broader set of financial losses depending on the actual drafting and contractual context.

Close reading of a real specimen

Hamilton's War and Cyber Operations Exclusion No. 4 is an LMA5567A amended 2023 specimen, hosted by the LMA. It contains three substantive branches: war, state cyber operations associated with war or immediate preparation, and state cyber operations that produce the specified impact on a state. Its third branch expressly extends to effects on relevant computer systems outside the impacted state. The title should not be mistaken for evidence that it retains every territorial provision of the unamended No. 4 model.

The sample defines an operation by both conduct and its relationship to a state. It defines impacted state by major detriment to state functioning through essential services or to defense or security, and war by armed conflict involving physical force. A technical finding about the attack is thus only one step: the defined operation, relevant impact or conflict nexus, and insured loss must all fall within the invoked branch.

The attribution provisions preserve the insurer's existing burden of proof and contemplate objectively reasonable available evidence, including possible official attribution from the government where the affected system is located. The specimen additionally provides negotiation and potential binding determination by a qualified disinterested umpire, with timing safeguards regarding limitations and litigation. These are features of this inspected specimen; they are not universal LMA rules. The enforceability and practical implementation of the procedure depend on law, the actual contract and facts.

The distinction between an attribution rule and a burden-of-proof rule is significant. An agreement about sources of evidence need not shift the ultimate burden of establishing an exclusion. A government statement can be persuasive without being contractually conclusive. An umpire's resolution of attribution may still leave questions about policy attachment, causation, valuation, and other exclusions. The contractual decision is most accurately described as a set of connected but separately contestable findings.

Mechanisms and Evidence for State Attribution

From technical observation to an insured event

Technical investigation establishes what occurred within the relevant systems, when it occurred, and how disruption developed. Records may include incident chronology, system logs, malware analyses, service availability, recovery records, independent assessments and evidence of prior state of the systems. Their value depends on provenance, integrity, relation to the incident and completeness. Attacker identity is a separate inference. A shared software tool may be used by different adversaries; a source address can reflect a compromised intermediary; indicators relating to one campaign may be copied or misinterpreted.

Rid and Buchanan's Attributing Cyber Attacks (2015) distinguishes tactical, operational, and strategic inquiry and relates attribution confidence to available expertise, time, and the stakes of a response. Their conclusion supports treating attribution as a graduated process of reducing uncertainty. For insurance purposes, a record of confidence and alternative explanations is more useful than a bare actor label, particularly when a policy requires control or direction by a state.

Consider a forensic report identifying a known operation with high confidence. It may establish that the same malware family was present in the insured's network. It does not automatically establish that the specific operation causing the claimed loss was commissioned by a state. Evidence of relationship to the state may come from intelligence, organizational affiliation, tasking or other reliable records. The precise significance of those facts depends on the definition in the contract. Attribution of a group across all its historical activity is especially problematic if a particular operation could have been independently motivated.

Public and international legal attribution

The United Nations' official note on the Articles on State Responsibility (2001) describes how the International Law Commission differentiates conduct of state organs and conduct of persons or groups directed or controlled by a state. These categories illuminate why the relationship between an actor and a state matters. International legal responsibility additionally requires the relevant legal elements of wrongfulness. Private exclusions may set their own textual thresholds, and a policy decision does not settle the international responsibility of a state. The ILC articles are not treated as a newly enacted global insurance code or as automatic policy definitions.

Government statements have additional characteristics. They can combine classified and public sources and can be intended for diplomatic action. Their evidential force depends partly on the specificity of the claim, date, scope, and transparency of reasoning available to the parties. Silence by a government does not prove that an event was privately motivated; issuing a statement does not by itself prove the loss amount or meaning of a policy's impairment threshold. Two governments' statements may rely on shared evidence, so their number is not necessarily the number of independent observations.

The UK attribution of NotPetya distinguished an intelligence assessment of high confidence from the government's judgment. Claims handling may encounter that distinction months or years after an event. Any procedure for revising a claim decision as evidence develops should align with the policy and applicable claims law. A delay in information is a source of reserve and liquidity uncertainty even if the ultimate allocation would be identical under earlier information.

Causation, materiality, and evidence intervals

Coverage usually requires a relationship between a loss and a covered event, and an exclusion requires the relationship expressed in the exclusion. Terms such as direct, indirect, caused by, arising from, or resulting from can have different effects within different legal systems. The study makes no universal claim that these expressions share a single legal test. For a complicated digital interruption, the relevant facts can include the initiating operation, failure of a dependency, reasonable mitigation, alternative means of operation, and independent causes of loss.

Suppose a state operation disrupts a service provider while a policyholder experiences revenue loss due partly to preexisting operational difficulties. The attribution record does not identify which part of that revenue loss belongs to the excluded event. A transparent chronology and a justified baseline for financial performance are needed. Separate expenses may be attributable to ordinary incident response, restoration, contractual liabilities or unrelated deterioration. Each must be assessed against the actual insuring agreement and exclusion.

The phrase state impairment creates another level of evidence. A large insured loss can occur while a state's essential services remain functional. Conversely, severe national disruption can affect many small enterprises without any one having a large direct loss. State-level impact and policyholder-level loss should be measured separately. Relevant indicators might include duration of the disruption, proportion of service capacity lost, availability of substitutes, territorial reach, and the functions impaired. The policy defines whether these indicators matter; the investigator cannot introduce an unagreed numerical threshold merely because a precise figure would be convenient.

The changing confidence problem

A simple probability illustration shows uncertainty without purporting to supply a legal proof standard. Assume an analyst assigns prior probability 0.20 to a specified state relationship for a defined campaign. Assume a hypothetical evidential finding is four times as likely under that relationship as under its absence. Prior odds are 0.25; multiplying by four yields posterior odds of 1, or probability 0.50. If a subsequent finding adds an independent likelihood ratio of three conditional on the hypothesis, the posterior probability becomes 0.75. Independence and likelihood ratios are assumptions, not measurements from this study.

If the second finding merely repeats evidence already used, multiplying by three is unjustified. Likewise, a probability of 0.75 cannot be mechanically converted into a conclusion on the actual burden of proof. The illustration concerns information updating only. A separate policy question remains whether actor involvement, war nexus, territorial requirements and causal language are satisfied. An insurer may quantify uncertainty for reserving without treating that probability as the dispositive legal rule.

Comparative Measurement of Coverage Determinations

The KA-SAT operation

Viasat's March 30, 2022 KA-SAT incident overview documented a partial disruption of a consumer-oriented satellite broadband partition on February 24. The company reported several thousand impacted customers in Ukraine and tens of thousands elsewhere in Europe. Other networks and directly managed mobility or government users were reported outside the affected service partition. Its account described investigation and restoration using both equipment reset and replacement pathways. This source describes system impact and company response; it does not provide a representative insurance-loss ledger.

The European Union's May 10 KA-SAT attribution declaration assigned the operation to Russia and connected its timing to the renewed invasion of Ukraine. The UK government's parallel attribution statement reported additional effects on European internet users and wind farms. These government assessments and the operator's account establish a valuable contrast between evidence about responsibility and evidence about disrupted technology. They are not evidence of the disposition of a particular commercial claim.

An assessment under a hypothetical policy would require independent answers about whether the state-related cyber conduct fell within the war branch, whether the impaired-state branch applied, the location of the relevant systems, whether a dependent business interruption grant attached, and how the insured measured loss. A territorial writeback might matter to a remote firm even where the initiating event occurred in a state undergoing armed conflict. The modified Hamilton specimen would pose a different question because its third branch includes specified extraterritorial system effects. No actual KA-SAT policy or claims determination is inferred.

Comparative evidence table

Observation NotPetya KA-SAT
Incident timing June 2017 February 24, 2022
Official attribution evidence examined UK statement, February 2018 EU and UK statements, May 2022
Operational relationship Digital disruption at affected businesses Shared satellite broadband service partition
Coverage evidence in reviewed corpus Merck appellate interpretation; reported settlements No verified policy-level determination
Inference supported Legacy wording can be contested independently of actor identity Cross-border system impact is a distinct coverage question
Inference unsupported Universal coverage or payout rate A determination that particular losses were insured or excluded

This comparison is analytically informative because the two incidents put different dimensions of the problem into view. It is not a matched-pair experiment. The conflicts, technologies, sectors, policy years, legal forums and available documents differ. Differences in the observed record may reflect publication and reporting processes as much as differences in actual insurance practice.

The claim denominator and selection problem

The correct denominator depends on the research question. The rate of war exclusion invocations among all cyber claims requires reliable counts of all claims and invocations in a defined portfolio and period. The share of claims denied under a war exclusion requires both final denials and an explicitly specified denominator, such as all closed claims. The acceptance rate of litigated exclusion defenses requires identified litigated decisions and consistent treatment of settlements and unresolved proceedings. None of these quantities equals a count of incidents assigned to state actors in a threat report.

The empirical work of Biener, Eling, and Wirfs (2014), Insurability of Cyber Risk, identifies 994 selected cyber loss incidents in an operational-risk database. Their analysis treats loss interdependence, information asymmetry, and data limitations as material insurability problems. The sample is not an insurance claims register or a census of cyber incidents; its composition cannot identify the probability that a state-backed attack produces an insured claim. Research on war exclusions therefore needs a separate denominator and observations of policy applicability, alongside incident counts.

A reporting system should permit one operation to generate multiple claims; each claim can have several coverage issues and more than one payment. A policy may span overlapping incidents, and a multinational program may place layers with multiple insurers. Simply dividing publicized coverage disputes by attacks produces a number with no stable economic interpretation. Publicized litigations disproportionately select large and contested losses; confidential adjustments and settlements disappear from the observed outcome distribution.

The NAIC's 2026 cybersecurity insurance report provides aggregate market context. Its displayed direct written premium series gives approximately USD 7.083 billion for 2024 and USD 7.459 billion for 2025, an increase of about 5.3 percent. This is that particular reported series, not a global estimate or a count of war exclusions. Other aggregate definitions may add different populations of insurers, policies or premium. An increase could reflect changes in exposure, price, policy count, limits, industry composition, reporting or several factors together. It cannot demonstrate that war exclusion risk declined or increased.

Cremer and colleagues' German cyber warfare insurance study (2024) explicitly addresses the protection gap associated with cyber warfare exclusions and the impact of such wording during the Russia–Ukraine conflict. Its institutional abstract supports this research characterization. The publisher's full text was not accessible in this session, so the present study does not repeat or infer its sample design, detailed findings, measured prevalence or recommendations. Germany contributes a documented scholarly research perspective, not an estimated national comparison with the London market.

Worked loss allocation

Assume a firm has a valid business interruption and restoration grant with USD 12 million eligible loss before exclusions, a single USD 1 million retention, and a USD 10 million limit. Ignore other policy constraints. For clarity, assume the retention applies once to the remaining covered amount after exclusion. If the event remains covered, payment equals min(10, max(12 − 1, 0)) = USD 10 million. If an applicable exclusion removes the entire loss, payment is zero. If a geographically defined exclusion removes USD 7 million but a separate USD 5 million is covered, payment is USD 4 million.

Under this assumed structure, the residual loss retained by the insured is USD 2 million, USD 12 million or USD 8 million, respectively. The physical loss and technology event are unchanged. Contract interpretation reallocates the loss. The example illustrates the effect of a single retention and one limit, not a universal order of policy calculations; a real contract may place deductibles, sublimits, aggregation and allocation differently.

Now assume an unresolved claim falls into the first outcome with probability 0.55, the second with 0.30 and the third with 0.15. The hypothetical expected payment is 0.55 × 10 + 0.30 × 0 + 0.15 × 4 = USD 6.1 million. This is scenario-weighted expected value without adjustment expenses, discounting or risk margin. It may inform an internal analysis of cash flows, but the numerical probabilities are invented and the calculation is not a recommended accounting reserve. A legal determination eventually resolves the applicable contractual outcome rather than settling by multiplying a limit by the analyst's probability.

A claim dataset capable of evaluating these effects should store the original loss measure, covered loss before contested exclusions, exclusions invoked with their version, amounts determined excluded or covered, retention, limit, adjustment expense, payments by date, procedural closure and the applicable jurisdiction. The policy should be recorded at inception and renewal. A finding that an exclusion was invoked must not be overwritten merely because it was later withdrawn. This would preserve the longitudinal evidence needed to examine disputes rather than just final loss amounts.

Integrated Scientific Synthesis and Research Agenda

Findings from the evidence

The first finding is that the factual question of actor involvement and the legal question of whether the exclusion reaches the loss can be decided separately. Merck illustrates a traditional wording dispute that did not require a resolution of the disputed attribution at the trial stage. A contemporary state-backed exclusion can expressly make state involvement material to a different set of predicates. The two approaches cannot be equated solely because both use the vocabulary of war.

The second finding is that the specificity of the contract materially conditions the financial effects of public attribution. Where wording preserves a burden of proof and treats official statements as possible evidence, a political attribution is not itself the entire decision process. Some contracts may specify other procedures. A researcher should examine the exact agreed text before categorizing a claim.

The third finding concerns geographic risk. Under a system-centered exclusion, the place of the insured corporation, place of disruption, provider location, and affected state need not coincide. The Viasat record establishes actual cross-border operational consequences; it does not identify which losses attached to which contracts. The examined Hamilton variant demonstrates that territorial treatment can be specified affirmatively within an exclusion. Thus geography is both a technology fact and a wording question.

The fourth finding is that removing a peril from the insured pool does not remove its social cost. Contractual exclusion may reduce underwriting exposure while increasing self-retained loss or demand for other mechanisms. Pricing and capital models should map the contractual portfolio rather than the total economic loss, while public policy should examine the latter as well. The illustrative variance and reinsurance calculations show why averages cannot describe all consequences of correlated events.

The fifth finding concerns measurement. Available market premium statistics and selected litigation establish the scale and nature of related questions, but they lack a common denominator for estimating exclusion frequency or outcomes. The actual industry incidence of denials associated with state-backed operations remains unidentified by this evidence. A universal statistic would require representative policy- and claim-level information.

Research design for testing coverage outcomes

Future empirical work should define the sampling frame by insurer market, jurisdiction, product form, underwriting years and policyholder class. Include active and expired policies, distinguish direct and ceded coverage, record the observation cutoff, and state whether policies with no claims enter the denominator. Collect final decisions and interim disputes, not only litigated cases. Preserve the version of the original wording and any amendments.

An outcome study of the 2023–2025 Lloyd’s transition could compare cohorts of otherwise similar risks with different inceptions and verified clauses, while accounting for simultaneous changes in security practices, threat environment, exposure, premiums, reporting and underwriting selection. A calendar discontinuity alone cannot identify the causal effect of a new exclusion if market participants changed other terms at the same time. A more credible study would identify how contracts changed within a defined portfolio and measure effects on claims, offered limits and retained exposure. No such dataset is available to this monograph.

Researchers should distinguish an operation identifier from each policy's claim identifier and retain separate attribution fields for technical actor, public governmental judgment, state relationship as alleged or found, source dates and dispute outcome. Competing or revised assessments should be represented rather than converted into a single immutable actor label. This allows later analysis of claims made before and after official statements.

Quality controls should address missing confidential cases, insurer reporting inconsistencies, loss development, inflation and changes in exposure. A claim paid in installments should not be counted as multiple independent incidents. Multi-insurer programs should prevent double counting direct and ceded payments in an industry-loss estimate. The study should stratify risk by policy terms rather than combine different products under a generic cyber label.

For quantitative stress analysis, scenarios should describe technical spread, operational effects, correlation assumptions, policy mix and reinsurance structure. The results should be conditional on the scenario and contract interpretation. Sensitivity to an alternative attribution finding and to different loss allocation rules should be visible. Model validation would require observed portfolio outcomes or other justified evidence and must remain distinct from showing internal arithmetic consistency.

Limits and editorial implications

This dossier establishes a bounded comparative account based on public document passages. It has not reconstructed the complete litigation docket, tested actual issued policies, measured international claim frequencies, or accessed classified intelligence. The German market study is used at abstract level; the Rid–Buchanan article and Biener–Eling–Wirfs paper are used only for the inspected passages of their published texts. The market bulletins provide dated evidence of requirements and specimen choices; a comprehensive effective-law audit across all jurisdictions and subsequent market updates was not performed. The legal findings should be read at the level of the identified sources. The numerical exercises describe hypothetical portfolios with fully specified simplifying assumptions. A formal claim of scientific novelty would require a broader literature review and is not advanced.

A coherent scientific treatment of this subject preserves the distinction between incident, attributed operation, contractual event, measured insured loss, indemnity and recoverable reinsurance. This conclusion derives from the comparative interpretation and calculations above. It is an ordinary analytical synthesis of existing materials, not a named new theory, doctrine, principle, or conceptual system.

Conclusion

Cyber insurance war exclusions allocate the financial consequences of cyber operations through defined contractual conditions. State attribution is a material component of many modern wordings, yet its significance depends on the scope of the exclusion, the nature of the operation, the required relation to war or state impairment, geographical provisions, causation, burden of proof and the insurance grant. The older hostile/warlike clause studied in Merck and the later Lloyd’s market framework demonstrate the importance of contract specificity.

The comparison between NotPetya and KA-SAT illustrates the transnational transmission of operational disruption and the difference between public attribution and insured claims. The analysis of a concrete specimen endorsement establishes that policy authors can specify territorial application and the process for resolving disputed attribution. The numerical exercises show that correlated technology risk and contractual mismatch can substantially change retained loss and capital exposure even when physical or operational damage remains the same.

Future knowledge about the real distribution of covered and excluded losses will depend on representative linked records of policies, incidents, claims, attribution evidence, litigation and reinsurance. Public documents yield meaningful historical and legal findings but do not supply the required denominator. The scientific task is to preserve the distinctions on which enforceable and measurable risk transfer depends.

References

  • Lloyd’s. (2022, August 16). State backed cyber-attack exclusions. Market Bulletin Y5381. Verified source

  • Lloyd’s. (2024, May 14). State backed cyber attack wordings. Market Bulletin Y5433. Verified source

  • Lloyd’s Market Association. (2023, January 18). Cyber war and cyber operation clauses. Bulletin LMA23-002-PD. Verified source

  • Lloyd’s Market Association. (2023). Cyber War & Cyber Operation Clauses Updates. Bulletin LMA23-003-PD. Verified source

  • Lloyd’s Market Association. (n.d.). Cyber war clauses. Clause classification and compliance assessment. Verified source

  • Hamilton. (2023). War and Cyber Operations Exclusion No. 4 (LMA5567A amended 2023). LMA-hosted specimen endorsement. Verified source

  • Lloyd’s Market Association. (2024). Model State-Backed Cyber War Exclusion Clauses for Cyber Treaty Reinsurance. Bulletin LMA24-011-CM. Verified source

  • Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. (2023, May 1). Merck & Co., Inc. v. ACE American Insurance Co., consolidated appeals A-1879-21 and A-1882-21. Verified source

  • Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. (2023, May 1). Merck & Co., Inc. v. ACE American Insurance Co. HTML reproduction, Justia. Verified source

  • Ebert, A. (2024, January 4). Merck $1.4 Billion Cyberhack Settlement Ends ‘Warlike’ Act Claim. Bloomberg Law. Verified source

  • Martin, A. (2022, October 31). Mondelez and Zurich reach settlement in NotPetya cyberattack insurance suit. The Record. Verified source

  • Foreign & Commonwealth Office and National Cyber Security Centre. (2018, February 15). Foreign Office Minister condemns Russia for NotPetya attacks. UK Government. Verified source

  • Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office. (2022, May 10). Russia behind cyber-attack with Europe-wide impact an hour before Ukraine invasion. UK Government. Verified source

  • Council of the European Union. (2022, May 10). Russian cyber operations against Ukraine: Declaration by the High Representative on behalf of the European Union. Verified source

  • Viasat, Inc. (2022, March 30). KA-SAT Network cyber attack overview. Verified source

  • United Nations Audiovisual Library of International Law. (n.d.). Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (2001). Introductory note and historical materials. Verified source

  • Rid, T., & Buchanan, B. (2015). Attributing cyber attacks. Journal of Strategic Studies, 38(1–2), 4–37. DOI: 10.1080/01402390.2014.977382. Verified source

  • Cremer, F., Sheehan, B., Mullins, M., Fortmann, M., Ryan, B. J., & Materne, S. (2024). On the insurability of cyber warfare: An investigation into the German cyber insurance market. Computers & Security, 142, 103886. DOI: 10.1016/j.cose.2024.103886. Verified source

  • U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2022, June). Cyber Insurance: Action Needed to Assess Potential Federal Response to Catastrophic Attacks. GAO-22-104256. Verified source

  • National Association of Insurance Commissioners. (2026). Report on the Cybersecurity Insurance Market. Reporting year 2025. Verified source

  • Biener, C., Eling, M., & Wirfs, J. H. (2014, June 11). Insurability of cyber risk: An empirical analysis. The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance—Issues and Practice. Advance online publication, 1–28. DOI: 10.1057/gpp.2014.19. Verified source

  • European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority. (2022). Supervisory statement on management of non-affirmative cyber exposures. EIOPA-BoS-22-414. Verified source