RESEARCH DOSSIER
Consumer Understanding of Insurance Exclusions and Claims
Abstract. Consumer understanding of insurance is best examined at the moment when a contract’s abstract promise becomes a decision about a particular loss. The consumer must distinguish an insured peril from an excluded cause, identify conditions on attachment and eligibility, anticipate a claim trigger, estimate net benefits after deductibles and limits, and execute a potentially demanding claims process. These tasks are neither equivalent nor necessarily correlated. A customer can recognize an exclusion in a document, misunderstand its application to an actual event, and subsequently interpret a legally defensible claim refusal as a broken promise. Conversely, contested denials may arise from deficient investigation or erroneous application of a contract despite accurate consumer understanding. This monograph develops an original comparative and methodological synthesis of peer-reviewed behavioral research, administrative insurance studies, primary legislation, supervisory standards, regulatory data and published dispute records. It separates textual comprehension from scenario application, calibrated expectations, procedural capability and realized outcomes; specifies empirical designs capable of identifying disclosure effects; and evaluates how contract wording, purchasing journeys, vulnerability and adjudication interact. Its central finding is that consumer understanding is a multi-stage, contract-specific capability whose adequacy must be tested against realistic claim scenarios and subsequent procedural tasks. Disclosure clarity matters, but improved readability alone cannot establish consumer protection, fair claims decisions or welfare gains. The study provides an operational research agenda and evidence-based institutional implications without proposing a new named theory or asserting experimental findings of its own.
Keywords: Insurance exclusions; insurance literacy; claims expectations; consumer comprehension; contract interpretation; waiting periods; insurance product information documents; behavioral economics; claims denial; dispute resolution; consumer protection; research design; insurance conduct supervision.
Introduction
An insurance transaction involves an exchange of a certain premium for contingent financial performance. Its effectiveness depends on the correspondence among contractual coverage, a purchaser's expectations, and the insurer's eventual decision. A premium is observable immediately; the conditions determining a future payment may remain untested for months or years. Consumers therefore purchase a representation of future protection while possessing incomplete information about future factual states, definitions, proof requirements and claim handling. The resulting uncertainty is economic, contractual and cognitive.
The distinction between a covered loss and an expected payment is foundational. A consumer might correctly identify “storm” as an insured peril yet assume that any water intrusion following rainfall qualifies. The policy may distinguish storm damage, gradual seepage, defective maintenance and flood; the eventual result may turn on the evidence of causation and the correct operation of an exclusion. A consumer's expectation is an observable belief; the correct contractual outcome requires a separate legal and factual analysis. The ombudsman's storm-damage guidance illustrates this difference with insurer evidence obligations and alternate sources of coverage.
The central research question is how individuals transform policy language and distribution-stage signals into predictions about their ability to make successful claims. The inquiry follows six linked domains: mental representation of coverage, interpretation of restrictions, anticipation of claim triggers, empirical assessment of comprehension, experience of disputes, and evaluation of institutional remedies. It engages the wider behavioral-insurance literature summarized by Kunreuther, Pauly, and McMorrow (2013) and modern supervisory concern with consumer outcomes, while retaining the separate legal disciplines of exclusion interpretation and claims adjudication.
The evidence base combines normative documents, original research reports, peer-reviewed studies, working papers, consumer surveys, administrative indicators, and selected individual disputes. Each has a different inferential status. Primary legal materials establish specified duties in their jurisdictions. Experiments identify behavior under their tested conditions. Supervisory observations identify defects within the inspected sample. Case studies reveal interpretive mechanisms and dispute procedure, without establishing prevalence. This is a documentary and analytical research monograph: it conducts no original human-subject experiment, does not reestimate proprietary administrative data, and does not present synthetic numerical outcomes as observations.
Policy Language and Mental Models
Insurance as a Conditional Promise
The formal object of an insurance policy is a contingent obligation specified through the insuring agreement, definitions, exclusions, conditions, limits, endorsements and temporal scope. A named-perils policy begins with a list of insured hazards; an open-perils or “all-risk” policy commonly establishes broader initial coverage subject to exclusions. The NAIC policy-structure explanation distinguishes these forms and identifies the function of declarations, deductibles and endorsements. This distinction matters cognitively because an apparently comprehensive label can encourage an excessively inclusive mental model unless the reader understands how exclusions operate.
Consumers frequently reason from the purpose of a product: home insurance protects the home, travel insurance protects the trip, and disability insurance protects income. Product purpose is a useful first approximation but a poor substitute for clause-level coverage. A claim may require an event within the insured peril, an insured property interest, an eligible policyholder, a valid time interval, satisfaction of notice or documentary conditions, and the absence of a decisive exclusion. One failing element can change an expected payment into a refusal or reduction. The consumer must reconstruct a conjunction of conditions rather than recognize an isolated word.
The distinction between a contractual term and its presentation is equally important. A short disclosure document can summarize a restriction accurately while leaving a complex boundary to be resolved by the complete contract. The EU standardized insurance product information regulation explicitly requires an IPID to point consumers to separate complete precontractual and contractual information. This architecture lowers immediate search costs but creates a second-step reading task. Clear summary language and easy access to the full policy must be assessed together.
A Taxonomy of Comprehension Tasks
Five task classes organize the inquiry. Recognition asks whether a purchaser can locate a restriction. Interpretation asks whether the purchaser can explain what a term means. Application asks whether the purchaser can classify a specified claim scenario. Calibration asks whether the purchaser's stated confidence matches correctness across scenarios. Procedural execution asks whether the purchaser can notify a loss, document a claim, understand a decision and seek review within applicable rules.
These tasks differ in observable difficulty. The statement “flood excluded” is readily recognized; an event that involves surface water, storm drainage, precipitation and subsequent seepage may demand much more inference. A deductible might be understood as “the amount I pay” while its specific operation—per claim, per event, percentage of insured value or interaction with a sublimit—remains misunderstood. Awareness of a claim deadline need not produce compliance when the clock starts from an unfamiliar trigger.
A useful research instrument records answers and confidence separately for each task, then compares them with a defensible contract-and-facts benchmark. Comprehension is not equal to reported confidence, self-rated literacy, reading speed, or satisfaction with the insurer. Nor does an insurer's internal coverage classification automatically provide a definitive benchmark when the underlying interpretation is contested. A reliable study must establish its benchmark through qualified contractual review and, for ambiguous cases, code the degree of legal uncertainty.
Coverage Inferences from the Purchase Journey
A purchaser gathers signals from a comparison site's category, quote questions, product labels, checked boxes, optional covers, agent explanations, advertising and price. These elements can become a substitute for a careful reconstruction of terms. In the 2025 Which? insurance-confusion study, participants confronted hypothetical travel and household claims scenarios and often expressed uncertainty or inferred coverage from the buying journey. A specific expectation that a loss outside one's control must be insured shows how a moral judgment about blame can displace the contractual peril definition.
Such observations establish plausible mechanisms, not universal error rates. Scenario responses depend on sample recruitment, exact wording and the selected policy benchmark. The survey cannot establish that every disappointed claimant misunderstood a condition, nor that a disclosure revision would have prevented every disputed outcome. Its scientific importance lies in identifying the inferential shortcuts that a subsequent randomized design could test.
The insurance choice literature offers an adjacent but distinct evidence stream. Handel and Kolstad (2015) combine administrative health plan choice and claims with survey measures of information frictions and hassle costs. Bhargava, Loewenstein, and Sydnor (2015) document financially dominated choices in a particular employer health-plan menu and examine explanations in follow-up hypothetical tasks. These findings show that complex insurance terms can influence economic choices through understanding and choice frictions. Their outcomes concern plan selection and financial dominance rather than a verified rate of exclusion misunderstandings in property claims; transferring a numerical estimate across these contexts would be an identification error.
The conditions under which a consumer interprets these promises deserve special attention. A disclosure task may be easy when the policy's class of peril is familiar, the claim description is short, and the consumer knows where to locate terms. Actual insurance decisions often occur under a different informational configuration. The contract may contain an insuring clause, a schedule, several endorsements, definitions and separate optional covers. A customer may have received revised renewal documents without comparing their differences. A product-comparison result may have used a standardized short feature label that does not identify all relevant limitations. A later claims decision may refer to a numbered endorsement the customer never consciously integrated into the original understanding of the product. These features create several distinct opportunities for errors: failure to find a relevant term, inaccurate interpretation of located language, incomplete integration of multiple clauses, and reliance on a superseded or incomplete version.
The distribution channel also changes the meaning of an apparently identical item of information. A restriction shown during a face-to-face conversation can be accompanied by a clarifying example or a mistaken informal assurance; a digital quotation page may show the same words amid numerous optional options; a price-comparison page may emphasize premium and excess rather than relevant scenario differences. The Which? purchasing-journey study supplies empirical motivation for examining how the overall journey produces beliefs. A defensible study should preserve a timeline of what the consumer could actually see, not simply attach a copy of the final contract and assume it was read. A complete exposure map records what was supplied, when it was supplied, the salience and accessibility of the restriction, and whether contradictory messages appeared elsewhere in the journey.
The boundaries among knowing, remembering and using information are also consequential. At the moment of sale, a customer may answer a multiple-choice exclusion question correctly after being directed to a paragraph. Six months later, the same customer may fail to retrieve that fact when a loss occurs. The distinction has operational consequences: a just-in-time reminder or contextual help screen may correct a retrieval problem even when redesigning the original disclosure has limited effect. Another consumer may remember the warning but still misunderstand the factual classification of a loss. For that case, realistic examples and explanation of causal boundaries are more important than additional repetition. The scientific task is to estimate which mechanism explains an observed mistake before selecting a remedy.
Insurance comparisons introduce an additional challenge. A consumer evaluating two contracts might understand the exclusions of each in isolation yet misjudge their relative protection. Equivalent commercial phrases can refer to different events, and distinct phrases can define functionally similar coverage. The relevant test asks the participant to rank policy performance across specified scenarios, calculate net indemnity under each, and identify which difference drives a preferred choice. The choice should be compared with explicitly elicited risk exposure and budget constraints rather than a researcher-imposed assumption that maximum coverage is universally optimal. Thus, consumer understanding includes cross-product discrimination, and the quality of the resulting decision requires a separate welfare criterion.
A final problem is the status of the benchmark itself. Even skilled insurance lawyers can disagree about a novel mixed-cause loss or an exclusion interacting with an endorsement. Treating a disputed clause as a straightforward “correct answer” artificially inflates measured consumer errors. Reviewers should produce a legal annotation explaining the words, governing law, relevant exclusions and unresolved interpretive issues. Items with genuine contestability should be reported separately or scored with a transparent uncertainty rule. The ombudsman's storm assessment demonstrates why causation and contractual classification require reasoned investigation. Scientific precision here consists in specifying the conditions for a warranted answer, not in pretending every contract has an obvious response.
Exclusions and Limitations
Contractual Structure and Behavioral Salience
An exclusion specifies a loss class, causal pathway, condition or risk that lies outside an otherwise applicable promise. An exception to an exclusion can restore coverage for a narrower set of events. A warranty, condition precedent, limitation, waiting period, deductible and sublimit have different operations, even when consumers group them under the general label of “fine print.” Claims research must preserve these distinctions: conflating an excluded peril with an incomplete filing, exhausted aggregate limit or nonpayment of premiums obscures both cognition and contractual remedies.
The importance of exclusions also depends on their visibility relative to coverage promises. A document that highlights “water damage” while relegating surface flooding to another section invites an asymmetric memory of the transaction. EIOPA's 2025 household catastrophe IPID review found instances of vague hazard definitions, disclosure of flood cover together with restrictions on precipitation-related flooding, unclear optional catastrophe add-ons, and less visible limits. Because EIOPA analyzed a sample of documents, these findings support the existence of such disclosure patterns within the inspected sample. They do not yield an EU-wide measured causal effect of IPIDs on claims outcomes.
The distinction between salience and understanding is substantive. Enlarging a warning can increase recall without enabling correct classification of a mixed-causation claim. A red exclusion symbol might help recognition but be irrelevant to the hard question of what counts as a named peril. A superior comprehension test uses multiple unfamiliar scenarios and asks respondents to cite the controlling contractual text, thereby separating memorization from transfer.
Waiting Periods, Deductibles and Benefit Conditions
Waiting periods define an interval during which benefits are unavailable or delayed, subject to the policy's exact construction; benefit deferment, elimination periods and moratoria are not necessarily synonymous. The start event could be policy inception, illness onset, disability commencement or another stipulated date. The correct outcome depends on that start rule, the event date and any exception. An effective disclosure must tell the reader what happens to a claim arising during the period, not merely announce that the product has a waiting period.
Deductibles affect payment magnitude rather than necessarily the status of a covered loss. Consider a hypothetical insured loss of $1,600 subject to a $500 per-occurrence deductible and no other adjustment: the simple arithmetic illustration yields $1,100, although real policy settlements can involve limits, valuation clauses and coinsurance. A zero payment where the covered loss falls below the deductible is different from a legal refusal on the basis of an exclusion. The Canadian claims guidance explicitly directs readers to exclusions, deadlines, relevant procedures and deductibles.
Benefit conditions can likewise affect eligibility and amount. In total and permanent disability products, functional tests and evidentiary requirements can materially shape claims experiences. ASIC's TPD claims thematic review examines Australian disability insurance practices and customers with unexpectedly poor outcomes. Its product-specific supervisory findings must not be recast as measured exclusion misunderstanding across insurance lines.
Misconceptions, Selection and Welfare
Insured losses are distributed unequally across consumers. A limitation rarely relevant to one purchaser may be decisive to another. If buyers overestimate a product's relevant protection, the misperception can change their valuation, purchase decision, willingness to retain risks and preparation for a loss. The welfare effect is therefore contingent on exposure, price, preferences, available alternatives and actual performance. A technically accurate disclosure might still have little welfare value if the consumer has no feasible substitute product; conversely, a single clearly communicated exclusion may improve a high-stakes choice.
Johnson and colleagues (1993) demonstrate that probability judgments and framing affect insurance decisions under experimental conditions. That result supplies a behavioral basis for investigating how consumers read exclusions, not a direct experimental estimate for a particular modern claims form. Behavioral mechanisms interact with economic constraints: liquidity, literacy, information access, intermediary incentives and the availability of more inclusive contracts may each explain observed purchase patterns.
Selection complicates evidence. People facing a higher hazard may read exclusions more carefully, choose additional cover or file more claims. Consumers who become complainants form a selected population with higher dissatisfaction or more complicated cases. Correlations between low comprehension and later denial may reflect underlying loss type, contract heterogeneity, education or differences in claims reporting. Identifying understanding itself as a cause requires a design that addresses those confounders.
An exclusion can operate through direct wording, defined terms, territorial restrictions, proximate-cause requirements, or the interaction of multiple policy sections. Researchers must avoid reducing these differences to a single “exclusion present” variable. The more relevant observation is whether the consumer can predict the result for an event within the restriction's actual domain. If a document excludes flood but includes escape of water from an internal appliance, the correct response to rainwater entering through a saturated drainage system may not follow from recognition of the word “water.” It requires a more precise causal narrative and, where pertinent, the applicable legal treatment of causation. The EIOPA catastrophe-document analysis demonstrates why home insurance is a particularly useful setting for such scenario-based tests.
A comprehensive coding protocol for restrictions should specify at least four attributes. The first is the relevant risk boundary: the event, condition, timing or cause that matters for indemnity. The second is textual location: the distance between the initial coverage promise and the qualification or exception. The third is structural dependence: whether the restriction is interpreted alone or alongside definitions, schedules, endorsements and governing rules. The fourth is consumer consequence: zero payment, reduced payment, delayed payment, postponed eligibility, additional evidence or loss of a procedural opportunity. These attributes describe existing features of contracts; they are variables for empirical documentation rather than a proposed new theory.
Temporal provisions are especially vulnerable to conflation. A claim reporting deadline is not the same as a waiting period. A preexisting-condition exclusion, an initial moratorium, a probation period, and a disability elimination period may each use different trigger dates and different tests of continuity. If consumers are asked a question merely saying “Is this covered in the first 90 days?”, they may choose different interpretations while all appearing equally certain. An informative item must specify the insurance start date, onset or occurrence date, diagnosis or notification date where relevant, and any contractual exception. The researcher should test which of those dates participants actually regard as controlling, preferably by requesting a short explanation after the classification.
Payment calculations require comparable care. Consider two illustrative contracts responding to the same $10,000 covered damage: one has a $1,000 fixed deductible and a $6,000 sublimit; another has a deductible equal to 5 percent of a $100,000 insured value, subject to a different cap. The ordinary arithmetic depends on the order and exact application of the deductible and sublimit. A question that omits those rules cannot have one assured answer. When testing numeracy, researchers should give the complete contract conditions, distinguish hypothetical figures from market data, and avoid scoring a plausible alternative interpretation as irrational. This also clarifies why a claimant receiving less than the perceived full loss may register a complaint without having misunderstood the underlying peril.
The selection of scenarios matters for welfare. An arbitrary test battery could devote equal attention to minor claims and an event that threatens household solvency. A population-specific instrument should identify common exposures, high-severity exposures and restrictions that could materially influence a policy choice. An event-by-event result can then be reported alongside a separately disclosed consequence-weighted summary. A weighted measure reflects study objectives and elicited exposure information; it is not an intrinsic property of consumer intelligence. Reporting the unweighted item-level results remains necessary so that policymakers and readers can inspect the consequence of that weighting decision.
Finally, some exclusion misunderstandings involve an interaction between consumer preference and insurer incentives. A salesperson may correctly present optional coverage but disproportionately emphasize an appealing headline because consumers select primarily by price or because compensation rewards conversion. A purchaser with limited time may find it rational to stop searching, even when relevant details remain unresolved. The scientific question is therefore not exhausted by whether individuals can recite policy conditions. It asks whether the communication environment supplies decision-relevant information at a time, in a form and under incentives that enable a capable comparison.
Claim Trigger Expectations
From Belief to a Falsifiable Scenario
A claim trigger is the event or state of affairs that initiates potential obligations, subject to contractual definitions and procedures. Its exact structure varies across occurrence, claims-made, indemnity, parametric, illness and disability contracts. Consumer research should specify the instrument at issue rather than treat “something bad happened” as a uniform trigger. For ordinary indemnity insurance, the question is whether a covered peril caused an insured loss while the insurance was in force, whether restrictions apply and what proof is necessary.
The empirical unit can be a policy–scenario–consumer triplet. Respondents first receive or select a definite product, then evaluate a scenario with clearly fixed facts. The researcher records coverage prediction, expected payment range, confidence, textual rationale and expected procedural actions. Qualified reviewers independently classify the same scenario from the full policy, recording ambiguity and divergent interpretations before consensus. Multiple policies and scenarios reveal whether a participant's apparent skill generalizes beyond a single familiar peril.
Calibration is evaluated by comparing confidence with correctness. A participant who answers correctly in 70 percent of defined benchmark scenarios but expresses 95 percent confidence shows overconfidence on the tested set. The sample proportion is descriptive; meaningful statistical inference requires uncertainty intervals, a prespecified evaluation rule and appropriately clustered observations where respondents evaluate several scenarios.
Measurement and Causal Identification
A robust experiment would randomly assign, within the same legally valid product, alternative authorized disclosure presentations: current standard text, shorter contextual explanations, matched coverage/noncoverage scenario cards, accessible layered formats and an interactive claims rehearsal. It would keep the actual insurance terms constant and disclose that the materials are research stimuli. Random assignment identifies the average effect of presentation on the measured outcome under the study's sampling and compliance assumptions; it does not identify a universal effect across insurance systems.
The primary outcome should be the preregistered share of correctly classified, policy-grounded scenarios rather than a generic satisfaction scale. Secondary outcomes can include perceived protection, confidence calibration, the ability to find the relevant clause, time needed, claim-filing intention, recall after a delay and procedural accuracy. Investigators should report absolute differences and confidence intervals, cluster standard errors when observations are repeated by consumer or product, and state multiple-testing adjustments. With randomization and clean implementation, the intention-to-treat contrast is the mean outcome under assigned format A minus that under assigned format B. No empirical treatment effect is claimed in this monograph.
A field extension would follow subsequent claims conditional on proper consent, privacy safeguards and a sufficiently long exposure horizon. Claims and adjudication records should distinguish attempted notification, submitted claims, withdrawn claims, denial reasons, partial approvals, final payments, complaint review and reversals. Randomized disclosures could affect the propensity to submit borderline claims as well as the proportion accepted. Consequently, a higher approval rate alone is an ambiguous measure of improved understanding: the denominator itself may have changed.
A quasi-experimental design may exploit a staggered implementation of disclosure amendments, provided adoption timing is plausibly unrelated to changing claims risk and trends. Difference-in-differences analysis requires credible comparable pretrends and careful handling of heterogeneous treatment timing. Instrumental variables require exclusion restrictions that are unlikely to be assured merely because a disclosure is sent through a different channel. Repeated surveys without identified exogenous variation can document associations but should not be described as causal evidence.
Administrative Outcomes and Denial Attribution
Regulatory claims rates are important market indicators with bounded meaning. The FCA's 2025 general-insurance value-measures release includes acceptance rates, frequency, payouts and complaints; the regulator explicitly warns of reporting inconsistencies, including home-insurance claim classifications. Product mix and counting rules affect comparability. An acceptance rate is neither the probability of payment for all covered losses nor a measure of consumer belief. Refusals may result from truly excluded events, incomplete evidence, misrepresentation, lapse, deductibles, ambiguous causation, insurer error or fraudulent claims.
An attribution study therefore needs a structured denial-code audit, independent sampling of files and linkage to original policy wording. It should classify at minimum: outside initial insuring clause, express exclusion, condition failure, waiting period, insured limit, no proven loss, factual uncertainty, document insufficiency, suspected fraud and administrative or insurer error. The study should report mixed reasons rather than force a single exclusive category where multiple grounds are operative. It should also identify outcomes overturned internally or by an ombudsman.
The regulatory objective differs from the scientific objective. Supervisors may use refusal patterns to prioritize inspection even before they can estimate an effect on consumer literacy. Researchers must avoid translating a screening indicator into a diagnosis of psychological misunderstanding. The FCA product-governance thematic review and its finite manufacturer/distributor sample offer institutional evidence of concerns about value and governance, not a representative experiment on what policyholders understand.
The design of scenario sets should begin with an explicit population and a defensible answer key. Claims researchers may wish to classify real loss descriptions extracted from administrative files; those descriptions often contain omissions, ambiguous temporal sequences or contested factual details. Rather than treat an insurer's final system code as the legal truth, independent reviewers should annotate each file after examining the policy version in force at the time, schedules, endorsements and material claim evidence. Reviewers should be blinded to the customer's comprehension score. Cases unresolved after adjudicative review can be retained as an uncertainty stratum. This approach separates the scientific assessment of understanding from the claims administrator's original decision.
At baseline, respondents should be asked what they believe the insurance will pay for before they read any research-provided summary. They should then complete a scenario assessment with the document available, and another assessment after a delay without necessarily having the document open. These designs answer different questions. The first measures spontaneous beliefs created by past distribution and ownership experience. The second measures the ability to use a document as an active reference. The delayed measure estimates retrieval and retention. Combining these scores would conceal whether the intervention changed a mental model, improved lookup skill or merely created temporary recognition.
An outcome should also be sensitive to two directions of error. False-positive coverage beliefs encourage expectations of protection where the contract does not provide it; false-negative coverage beliefs can cause unnecessary insurance purchases, failure to claim a valid benefit or avoidable anxiety. An intervention that reduces the first while substantially increasing the second need not improve consumer welfare. A useful confusion matrix records the four outcomes: predicted and actually covered; predicted covered but excluded; predicted excluded but covered; and predicted excluded and actually excluded. Because ground truth can be contested, the report must state the benchmark source and the share of cases excluded from unequivocal scoring.
Respondents can also express a payment probability or expected net payment rather than choose a binary outcome. Such questions capture beliefs about the combined effects of peril classification, factual proof, deductibles, sublimits and operational handling. Care is needed because uncertainty about future evidence is legitimate even when the contract's words are understood. Researchers should differentiate confidence in interpreting the contract from subjective confidence about proving the physical cause. A participant who knows the correct storm clause but lacks wind-speed observations may be appropriately uncertain; describing this uncertainty as illiteracy would misclassify rational behavior.
A particularly informative experimental design examines interactions between treatments. Simplified language may help participants with greater reading difficulty, while scenario explanations may help those who recognize the words but struggle with causal application. A layered interactive tool might improve claim-filing competence while lengthening the purchase process. If multiple interventions are compared, preregistration should identify whether the primary question concerns overall format superiority, a specific interaction or outcomes among prespecified groups. Researchers should report sample sizes, assignment balance, attrition, missing responses and possible learning between repeated scenarios. Subgroup findings require adequate power and correction for extensive exploratory comparison.
Field measurements have a longer horizon and heavier privacy obligations. Linking survey answers to policy and claims files can expose health, financial or household-loss information. Investigators should minimize collection, obtain an appropriate legal basis for processing, control access, document retention and enable independent review where relevant. A survey's consent to answer comprehension questions is not itself a universal permission to link identifiable claims histories. An ethically and legally defensible data design must respect the jurisdiction and source of the records, particularly when products concern medical exclusions, disability and family finances.
Reporting causal estimates should maintain explicit denominators. Suppose an experimental explanation increases the share of correctly classified noncovered situations among observed participants. If the explanation also persuades some people to buy additional coverage, the later claims population will differ between groups. An observed change in denial rates may reflect changes in selected risks, contracts and claim reporting as well as understanding. A credible analysis traces the sequence rather than imposing a single causal interpretation on the last observed percentage. This caution follows the broader need to separate information friction, preferences and outcomes in Handel and Kolstad's insurance-choice study.
Disclosure Comprehension Testing
European and United Kingdom Disclosure Systems
The EU Insurance Distribution Directive places conduct and information duties in insurance distribution, while Regulation 2017/1469 prescribes the standardized non-life IPID structure: what is insured, what is not insured, restrictions, territorial coverage, obligations and time limits among other headings. Article 5 requires plain language, and the full contract remains a separate legal source. A standardized document is a disclosure intervention embedded in a distribution system, not a legal guarantee that all consumers will interpret every contract correctly.
EIOPA's sample-based catastrophe disclosure analysis provides an especially pertinent stress test. It identifies descriptions of flood, hazards, optional add-ons and limits that can generate unwarranted protection expectations. The research implication is to test the same phrase in three contexts: recognition in an IPID, application to a realistic combined-peril vignette, and comparison with the underlying full policy. Document conformity and decision accuracy are separate outcome measures.
In the United Kingdom, ICOBS product-information provisions direct firms to consider complexity, customers' abilities, significant exclusions and obligations, including the information shown on an IPID. The FCA's Consumer Duty understanding provisions address communications across the retail-customer relationship where applicable. The regulator's 2026 consumer-understanding good practice describes testing with actual customers, A/B designs, accessible communications, highlighting exclusions early and monitoring post-change outcomes. These are jurisdiction-specific expectations rather than universal legal commands to insurers everywhere.
A legal comparison requires another distinction. The UK's Consumer Insurance Act 2012 regulates consumers' reasonable-care representations; among the circumstances relevant to care are the clarity of insurer questions and explanations. The Insurance Act 2015 section 11 concerns certain risk-reduction terms and losses for which noncompliance could not have increased the actual risk, with express scope limits. Neither instrument provides an automatic general remedy for every misunderstood exclusion. The proper doctrinal inquiry must identify the relevant provision, contract class, actual wording and loss facts.
United States, Australia and Canada
United States homeowners' coverage is governed through policy language and state law. The NAIC consumer explanation distinguishes named-perils and open-perils structures and explains the ordinary role of exclusions and deductibles. The NAIC model-laws catalogue identifies model unfair-claims-settlement instruments, but the existence of a model must be distinguished from state legislative or regulatory adoption and enforcement. An international claim about a uniform American legal remedy would require a state-by-state inquiry beyond the evidence assembled here.
Australia contributes a supervisory comparison rather than a direct legal equivalent to the EU IPID. ASIC's review of TPD claims concerns disability insurance claims practices and higher-than-predicted refusal patterns in its inspected setting. Its methodological value is the attention to actual claims outcomes and administrative behavior, showing why a disclosure-only review cannot exhaust consumer harm. Its product-specific observations should be studied alongside, and not substituted for, comprehension experiments.
Canada's federal consumer claims instructions offers an educational comparison: people are advised to check the event covered, exclusions, notice procedures and filing timelines, and to consider deductibles and future premiums. This illustrates a common procedural burden across jurisdictions without asserting identical national contract law. A cross-country study would code national and provincial law, product type, distribution mode and complaint institutions separately.
Experimental Design and Accessibility
A defensible disclosure study uses a transparent sample frame, inclusion criteria, accessible participation methods, independently reviewed policy scenarios, randomized assignment where feasible, a registered primary outcome, and predeclared handling of ambiguous items. Materials must preserve the financial and legal substance of the product, because changing the insured risk at the same time as the explanation prevents clean identification of the communication effect.
Researchers should oversample groups whose needs may differ—older consumers, first-time policyholders, readers with limited numeracy, people using assistive technologies, and speakers of languages other than the contract language—while specifying external-validity limits. The IAIS fair-treatment application paper recognizes diverse consumer capabilities and a lifecycle approach covering product design, communication, claims and complaints. Accessible formatting should be assessed by successful task completion, not by conformance with a style checklist alone.
A two-stage protocol can separate acquisition from retention. At the purchase stage, participants classify scenarios and choose among otherwise comparable policies. After a realistic delay, they receive a loss notification and must determine which action to take. Researchers then assess whether information survives outside the sales context. The long-run effect may depend on retrieval aids, reminder channels, claims staff and digital navigation; a short comprehension gain immediately after reading does not establish those outcomes.
The comparative evidence also exposes a fundamental tension in measuring successful disclosures. In the EU, presentation rules make a common structure available for insurance purchasers, but the presence of identical headings does not establish comparable policy wording. In the UK, the Consumer Duty examines customer outcomes throughout a lifecycle that includes purchase, renewal, claims and support. In US state-based systems, the same product label can have different authorized forms and legal interpretation across jurisdictions. Comparing these regimes requires instruments that hold constant the underlying insurance claim scenarios and identify where legal variation itself changes the benchmark answer. Without such controls, different success rates in national tests may simply reflect different coverage or products.
The starting point is a jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction legal dossier for every sampled policy. It should document the source and effective version of any required product summary, relevant statutory and regulatory provisions, policy forms, endorsements, and the available redress process. A rulebook obligation about the timing or clarity of disclosure cannot be treated as direct proof of how much a customer understood. Conversely, evidence of low comprehension does not by itself prove that a particular legal duty was violated. Legal compliance and actual cognition are separate variables, and the strength of their relationship is an empirical question. The EU IPID format regulation and the FCA customer-understanding rules provide primary bases for two distinct approaches to informational governance.
In conducting controlled tests, document design can be varied across several dimensions: text density, organization, visual contrast, specific examples, presence of an explicit uncovered scenario, graphical explanation of a deductible, and availability of an accessible alternative format. The experiment must distinguish each factor from the others. Replacing a long document with a shorter one that also changes the order and examples cannot isolate the effect of simplicity itself. Such a combined intervention may be appropriate for a practical rollout but should be described accordingly in the analysis. Research should measure navigation, reading time and contract application, not simply immediate recognition of the phrases emphasized by the treatment.
Regulator-issued templates also reveal the difficulty of standardized comparisons where contracts are heterogeneous. If two products use the same “What is not insured?” heading but apply different definitions of a storm event, a standardized display can help readers find the difference while not itself resolving the comparison. A test should therefore ask whether purchasers can identify relevant differences across the two policies and select appropriate additional cover where available. The EIOPA natural-catastrophe review makes such a design particularly pertinent for flood and storm disclosures.
The treatment of disability, language and financial literacy should be explicit. Participants using screen readers should be tested with the actual accessible materials, including how definitions and excluded events are read aloud. Linguistic adaptation should be checked for semantic fidelity to the legally controlling wording; a translated explanation that suggests a broader promise than the source contract can improve superficial comprehension scores while producing false confidence. Numeracy accommodations can be tested separately from legal-language simplification. Firms should distinguish accessible channels from the separate question whether the reader correctly anticipates claim decisions. IAIS inclusive-consumer guidance reinforces the need to examine consumer capability across the product lifecycle.
Finally, policy documents are often revised. A study that assesses only a newly issued disclosure may fail to observe whether long-standing customers still rely on prior coverage assumptions. Renewal tests should examine whether consumers identify material changes, whether endorsements alter an earlier promise, and whether a renewal reminder preserves or displaces relevant knowledge. The appropriate benchmark is the contract actually in force for the hypothetical loss. If the research team cannot determine which version of a document governed a claim, the episode should be classified as source-incomplete rather than assigned an invented correct answer.
Claims Disputes and Learning
Evidence, Causation and Interpretation
A dispute commonly involves three questions: what the contract promises, what caused the loss, and whether the evidence satisfies the applicable burden. Consumer understanding concerns the first question and beliefs about the second and third; insurer fairness additionally depends on a correct investigation and defensible reasoning. A misleading rejection letter can create uncertainty even for a well-informed policyholder.
The Financial Ombudsman Service storm-and-wind-speed case study describes a dispute in which policy wording did not specify the asserted wind threshold, and wear-and-tear exclusions were confined to a different part of the cover. The case shows why reading the correct section and identifying which exclusion applies matter as much as detecting exclusion keywords. It is evidence of one adjudicated set of facts, not proof that insurers generally invent storm thresholds.
In the gradual-damage ombudsman guidance, the reasoning distinguishes gradual causes, wear and tear, concealed leakage and the consumer's reasonable ability to detect damage. Outcomes depend on policy and facts. Likewise, guidance on pre-existing medical conditions emphasizes customers' awareness and understanding of relevant exclusions when disputes are evaluated. These materials demonstrate how legal and equitable assessment can incorporate communication quality while preserving the fact-specific nature of the result.
Dispute Feedback and Claims Friction
A denial may teach a customer about coverage, but learning is neither automatic nor necessarily accurate. A claimant may receive a generic letter, infer that all insurers behave the same way, misread an exception, or abandon a complaint because evidence gathering is costly. A successfully resolved dispute may reveal an insurer's initial error rather than a consumer's prior ignorance. Researchers should therefore treat complaints as a process with stages: trigger, explanation received, comprehension checked, response or evidence supplied, review, final disposition and subsequent belief updating.
Claims friction creates welfare effects beyond indemnity. Time spent obtaining documents, loss of access to repair funds, stress, delayed recovery and costs of navigating complaints can reduce the practical value of valid coverage. The empirical tasks are to measure such burdens separately from the gross claim and to identify whether complexity is contractual, procedural, informational or administrative. Handel and Kolstad's information-friction analysis supports attention to such costs in insurance choice, though its survey constructs are not a direct measurement of complaints handling.
When claim outcomes are used for institutional monitoring, separation of substantiated denials from contested reversals is essential. Otherwise a firm that resolves disputes quickly could appear to have an unfavorable initial-denial rate, while another firm could suppress formal complaints. A credible reporting system uses multiple denominators and follows cases over time. The FCA's value measures data are useful for surveillance, while their acknowledged coding limitations warn against simple league tables.
Source Criticism and External Validity
The evidence reviewed has uneven strengths. Randomized vignette tests can identify presentation effects on scenario answers, yet hypothetical behavior may differ from behavior during a costly actual claim. Observational employee health-plan research measures choices and costs, but does not directly reveal an exclusion's application to a disputed household loss. EIOPA's documentary analysis identifies language problems, without testing every consumer. Regulator inspections have information unavailable to public researchers, but inspected firms may be purposefully selected. Ombudsman cases provide rich mechanisms but are conditional on escalation.
The 2025 Which? consumer confusion findings and EIOPA's NatCat IPID findings converge on the concern that ordinary readers may overgeneralize coverage from a product's headline or ambiguous hazard label. This convergence strengthens the relevance of the research question. It does not produce a pooled prevalence estimate: the studies differ in geography, method, units of observation and measured outcome.
The House of Lords committee evidence also relates inadequate purchase-stage understanding to later claims problems, but parliamentary testimony is not a controlled causal design. The 2025 EIOPA consumer-trends survey offers a wider observational lens on trust and experiences rather than an adjudicated classification of exclusion comprehension. The proper synthesis carries each evidentiary boundary forward instead of collapsing heterogeneous instruments into a synthetic percentage.
Dispute research becomes more informative when the reason for a rejection is examined as a sequence of decisions rather than as a single final code. A typical file may begin with a recorded event description, an initial interpretation of the insuring clause, requests for photographs or expert reports, an internal coverage recommendation, communications to the claimant and a formal decision. If a consumer receives a broad exclusion citation and subsequently submits material proving an exception, the initial denial and the ultimate entitlement need not match. Conversely, the claimant might have believed a peril was covered when the contract unambiguously excluded it, and the insurer's handling could still have been timely, courteous and consistent with applicable duties.
For longitudinal research, a denial letter should be coded for explanatory quality independently of legal correctness. Possible fields include whether it quotes the actual operative clause, identifies the factual premise, distinguishes coverage scope from proof insufficiency, describes what additional evidence could alter the result, names available review paths, and gives relevant deadlines. These are observable communication attributes. Their relationship to consumer understanding can be tested through randomized letter formats or structured before-and-after comprehension measures. The Financial Ombudsman gradual-damage guidance and published storm case show why clause placement and causal explanation can be decisive in contested losses.
A claims-denial rate cannot have a universal evaluative direction. High levels of valid claim payments may indicate broad insurance coverage or efficient claims handling; they could also reflect a clientele exposed primarily to simple covered losses. A low acceptance rate may reflect a high share of genuine exclusions, poor pre-sale explanations, problematic product design, deficient adjudication or changes in claim notification. Firms can also alter their statistics by encouraging customers to make informal inquiries that never become recorded claims. Comprehensive research must observe the registration boundary and distinguish prospective claims, inquiries, notifications, submitted claims, settled claims and appeals. The FCA insurance value-measures statistics illustrate both the usefulness and the limitations of administrative performance information.
Ombudsman activity is similarly selected. Customers who know their rights and can assemble documentation may escalate more often than customers who lack time, language support or digital access. A higher proportion of successful formal complaints might therefore indicate better access to redress, increased initial insurer error, greater complexity or a change in the composition of complainants. The evaluator should track how many customers know that the process exists, how many start it, which groups withdraw, and what amount of time or expenditure they bear before resolution. Complaint reversals can identify a subclass of initially questionable decisions without providing a full prevalence measure for all claims.
Learning after loss has several dimensions. A consumer may learn the coverage rule, update expectations about future products, change willingness to purchase coverage, or conclude that claiming is too burdensome. These outcomes can move in different directions. An accurate explanation of a denied loss may correct a misconception but also reduce general trust in insurance; a prompt reversal may restore trust while revealing that the initial decision was defective. The science of learning therefore requires repeated measures and attention to the difference between justified risk beliefs and generalized distrust. The EIOPA consumer-trends survey provides broader consumer-perception context but is not a replacement for longitudinal linked claims evidence.
The long-term practical question is whether consumers can convert valid contractual rights into realized benefits. A policy that provides legal coverage but makes proof operationally inaccessible may deliver much less effective protection than buyers anticipate. This issue extends beyond disclosure wording into claims management, dispute systems, intermediaries and public supervision. Distinguishing these institutional mechanisms allows researchers to attribute harm to the relevant process and devise an intervention that can actually address it.
Behavioral Consumer Protection
Product Design, Communication and Supervision
Effective policyholder protection begins with terms that can be translated into understandable decisions. Product manufacturers can define frequently contested perils with examples and material boundaries, explain important exclusions at the point of choice, and align comparison interfaces with what the policy will actually pay. Distributors can identify optional add-ons and ensure that sales questions are not mistaken for coverage guarantees. Claims personnel can give clause-specific reasons and indicate what evidence would matter in review.
Supervisory arrangements establish complementary duties across the product lifecycle. IAIS Insurance Core Principles articulate global supervisory expectations of fair conduct, while the 2025 inclusive-consumer paper attends to variation in users' capacities. The FCA's Consumer Duty explanation links customer understanding with support, and its 2026 good-practice review calls for integrated design, testing and monitoring. The European IPID structure can make restrictions more discoverable; meaningful verification still requires consumer performance on the relevant decisions.
Institutional implementation should prioritize high-consequence misunderstandings. The costs of misclassifying a minor deductible differ substantially from those of assuming that uninsured catastrophe damage is covered. A risk-sensitive approach weights scenario importance by the financial exposure, prevalence in the target population and practical ability of customers to avoid or mitigate the uncovered hazard. The weighting is an analytical evaluation choice that must be disclosed, not an empirically established universal metric.
Implementation and Measurement Priorities
A feasible improvement cycle starts by mapping common claims and complaints to exact source clauses, not merely counting confusing words. It then creates realistic scenario items, tests alternative explanations with the relevant population, reviews errors by product and consumer group, revises materials, and monitors renewal or later claims. Product teams should report how the actual restrictions were preserved and whether improved understanding led to better choices or procedural results.
Useful indicators include (a) correct classification of covered and uncovered scenarios; (b) false-positive beliefs about payment; (c) false-negative beliefs that valuable coverage is unavailable; (d) calibrated confidence; (e) ability to name the responsible clause; (f) claim-notification competence; (g) corrected misconceptions after claims explanations; and (h) actual complaints and reversals, suitably risk-adjusted. These indicators have different denominators and should remain separate in reporting.
The most useful experiment may be narrowly targeted. For example, a randomized explanation of flood, surface water and storm damage can test whether applicants correctly classify the scenarios that EIOPA found confusing. Improvements in immediate classification can be measured before any field deployment. If field deployment follows, the insurer must track whether the clarified information changed take-up of optional flood cover, claim submission and claim outcomes. The research inference is strongest where each stage is observed and alternative pathways are checked.
Distributional and Welfare Consequences
Disclosure reform has distributional implications. Consumers with greater time and financial capability can absorb long contract texts or consult advisors; people facing language, disability, numeracy, time or digital barriers may rely on simplified labels. Equal access to a document does not imply equal capacity to act upon it. A policy that is easier to understand but unavailable or unaffordable may increase awareness of an uncovered risk without creating an immediately attainable alternative.
At the same time, more precise exclusion disclosure can lower false claims expectations, reduce wasted filing costs and reveal where insurance products offer too little protection for their stated purpose. It can also expose gaps that warrant product redesign rather than another warning. The FCA's product-governance review addresses fair value and distribution arrangements in a supervised sample; the inference is institutional rather than an estimate of the welfare effect of any single disclosure sentence.
This monograph's synthesis supports a practical ranking of evidence rather than a new doctrinal system. Strong confidence in an intervention's effect requires an observable correct-answer benchmark, randomized or otherwise credibly identified change, representative users and meaningful outcomes. Regulatory guidance and documentary comparison identify where to intervene; controlled testing determines whether the intervention improves understanding; outcome monitoring determines whether its effects survive the real contract lifecycle. These are complementary research activities.
An institutional program capable of putting these results into practice requires coordination among product manufacturers, distribution teams, claims functions, compliance, researchers and supervisors. Manufacturers should identify the restrictions most likely to create materially mistaken expectations for the product's target market. Distributors should compare headline descriptions with the binding contract, especially where an optional add-on determines an important peril. Claims departments should record both the legal ground of a refusal and the informational pathway through which the consumer was told about that ground. Monitoring teams should preserve the possibility that a customer misunderstands an accurate explanation and the possibility that an insurer gives an inaccurate one.
Product design review should begin with a map of material insured and uninsured scenarios rather than a purely textual reading score. For each scenario, the review should record the underlying loss, cause and timing, the controlling clauses, the expected net benefit and the disclosure location. It can then ask whether consumers make the correct comparative choice or claim classification. A legally valid contract can remain costly to use because of an opaque user journey; revising the journey and verifying understanding offers a direct way to investigate that burden. The FCA consumer-understanding review supplies official support for end-to-end testing and monitoring, including attention to limitations that sales-focused indicators miss.
Supervisory evidence should be handled with methodological discipline. Findings from a thematic inspection are not prevalence estimates for every insurer. A sample of product information documents supports conclusions about the examined texts, not an estimated effect on all policyholder behavior. Published cases illustrate disputed legal reasoning without establishing the general incidence of wrongful refusal. A randomized scenario experiment provides stronger internal evidence about presentation effects, but only for its tested population, exposures and outcomes. A credible welfare assessment links interventions with consumer choice, coverage costs, experienced losses and realized claims. These distinctions are important because interventions will otherwise be judged using inappropriate substitutes for their actual objectives.
There is a practical trade-off between detail and usability. Condensing a policy into a few sentences may improve readability but remove a qualification necessary for accurate anticipation of a claim. An overloaded document may preserve every qualification while making the relevant ones invisible. A layered explanation can keep an accessible summary alongside an easily retrievable full clause and context-specific examples. Its superiority must be established empirically, with tests of both recognition and correct transfer to unfamiliar claims. User-facing information must maintain the legal substance of the cover; an explanation that promises more than the contract provides can be particularly harmful for catastrophic exposures.
Institutional resources can be allocated through risk-based testing. The first priority is a high-consequence misconception observed among the target customers and attached to a plausible claims situation; the next is a practical change capable of correcting that misconception; the final stage is evidence that the change operates when the loss occurs. A firm should document why selected scenarios are material, how comprehension is measured, whether disadvantaged consumers benefit, and what unwanted effects arise. The FCA product-governance thematic evidence provides a complementary regulatory reason to integrate such work into product review rather than leave it solely with legal drafting.
The international evidence supports a research agenda attentive to timing, causation, distribution and procedural capability. Consumers require accurate knowledge before purchase, usable reminders at renewal or loss, clear investigation and reasons after submission, and accessible opportunities to challenge erroneous decisions. Scientific claims about improvement should specify the particular stage, outcome and population to which they apply. No unmeasured aggregate claims acceptance rate should substitute for those observations; no generic statement that contracts are complex should substitute for direct assessment of the most important restrictions. The result is an actionable comparative assessment grounded in verifiable documents and explicit research design.
Conclusion
Consumer understanding of insurance exclusions and claims is a distinct, consequential empirical object. It comprises recognizing restrictions, interpreting their precise operation, applying them to factual scenarios, estimating expected payments and executing the procedure necessary to realize valid benefits. A document can be readable without producing accurate mental models; a disappointed claimant can have misunderstood a contract, encountered an unfair decision, or experienced both problems. Scientifically credible research must distinguish these pathways.
Behavioral studies establish that insurance choices are shaped by framing, information frictions and limited command of complex plan features. EIOPA's documentary work demonstrates concrete ambiguity in catastrophe disclosures; Which?'s scenario-based evidence reveals recurring misconceptions among studied UK consumers; regulatory materials specify duties, data sources and dispute-handling expectations within their respective jurisdictions. These sources converge on the importance of understanding while differing materially in their ability to identify causal effects.
The analytical result is a research and governance agenda grounded in exact contracts and observed decisions. Exclusion language should be tested in realistic, independently benchmarked claim scenarios; procedural requirements should be included in comprehension instruments; outcomes should be measured beyond the act of disclosure; and claims data should be interpreted with attention to selection, denominators, coding and reversals. Fair protection ultimately requires alignment among contractual substance, explanations, user capability and competent claims administration. This is an original comparative synthesis of established research and public sources, without a claim to a new named scientific theory, original field-data discovery or external peer review.
References
Handel, Benjamin R., and Jonathan T. Kolstad. 2015. “Health Insurance for ‘Humans’: Information Frictions, Plan Choice, and Consumer Welfare.” American Economic Review 105(8): 2449–2500. DOI 10.1257/aer.20131126. Verified source.
Bhargava, Saurabh, George Loewenstein, and Justin Sydnor. 2015. “Do Individuals Make Sensible Health Insurance Decisions? Evidence from a Menu with Dominated Options.” NBER Working Paper 21160. DOI 10.3386/w21160. Verified source.
Johnson, Eric J., John Hershey, Jacqueline Meszaros, and Howard Kunreuther. 1993. “Framing, Probability Distortions, and Insurance Decisions.” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 7: 35–51. Verified source.
Kunreuther, Howard C., Mark V. Pauly, and Stacey McMorrow. 2013. Insurance and Behavioral Economics: Improving Decisions in the Most Misunderstood Industry. Cambridge University Press. DOI 10.1017/CBO9781139050319. Verified source.
European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA). 2025. Natural Catastrophes, Is Your Home Covered? Findings from a Sample-Based Analysis on the Clarity of NatCat Coverage in Household Insurance Product Information Documents. May 19. Verified source.
Which? 2025. Risky Business: Consumer Confusion Around General Insurance. January 16. Verified source.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 2026. Insurance: Conduct of Business Sourcebook, ICOBS 6, Product Information, including Annex 3 (Insurance Product Information Document). Version viewed November 2026. Verified source.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 2026. Consumer Understanding: Good Practice and Areas for Improvement. March. Verified source.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 2026. General Insurance Value Measures Data 2025. Published July 21, updated September 11. Verified source.
European Commission. 2017. Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/1469 of August 11, 2017, Laying Down a Standardised Presentation Format for the Insurance Product Information Document. Official Journal L 209: 19–23. Verified source.
European Parliament and Council. 2016. Directive (EU) 2016/97 of January 20, 2016, on Insurance Distribution. Official Journal L 26: 19–59, as amended. Verified source.
International Association of Insurance Supervisors (IAIS). 2024. Insurance Core Principles and ComFrame, updated December 2024, including ICP 19 Conduct of Business. Verified source.
International Association of Insurance Supervisors (IAIS). 2025. Application Paper on Fair Treatment of a Wide Range of Consumers. July 7. Verified source.
National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Model Laws: Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (Model 900) and related claims model regulations. Accessed November 2026. Verified source.
National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). 2012. Understanding Your Homeowners or Renter’s Policy. Consumer Insight. Verified source.
United Kingdom. 2012. Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, sections 2–4, as amended. Verified source.
United Kingdom. 2015. Insurance Act 2015, section 11, Terms Not Relevant to the Actual Loss. Verified source.
Financial Ombudsman Service (UK). n.d. Insurer Declines Storm Damage Claim Because of Local Wind Speeds. Case Study. Verified source.
Financial Ombudsman Service (UK). n.d. Gradual Damage. Technical Guidance for Businesses. Verified source.
Financial Ombudsman Service (UK). n.d. Pre-Existing Medical Conditions. Technical Guidance for Businesses. Verified source.
Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). 2019. Report 633: Holes in the Safety Net: A Review of TPD Insurance Claims. October 17. Verified source.
Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC). 2025. Making an Insurance Claim. Government of Canada. Verified source.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 2024. TR24/2: General Insurance and Pure Protection Product Governance Thematic Review. August 21 (updated December 2025). Verified source.
European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA). 2025. Eurobarometer 2025: Consumer Trends in Insurance and Pension Services. December 10. Verified source.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 2026. About the Consumer Duty. Updated October 23. Verified source.
Financial Ombudsman Service (UK). n.d. Storm Damage. Technical Guidance for Businesses. Verified source.
Financial Services Regulation Committee, House of Lords. 2026. Home and Travel Insurance Regulation: More for the FCA to Do, chapter on claims and consumer understanding. Verified source.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 2026. PRIN 2A.5: Consumer Duty—Retail Customer Outcome on Consumer Understanding. FCA Handbook. Verified source.